Enter your zip to
find local pros.

Siding

Home Siding Replacement Guide

On this page:
  • ROI for siding replacement
  • When to replace siding
  • Best types of siding to choose

Find the best siding contractors in your area.

Home Siding Replacement

If you have owned your home for handfuls or decades of years, a refreshing your home’s siding has probably crossed your mind once or twice. A siding replacement project provides several benefits to your home. Aesthetically, it gives your home a new makeover and boosts its curb appeal. At the same time, replacing siding increases home value and makes it more appealing to prospective homebuyers, should you decide to sell.

Perhaps more importantly, new siding also protects your home’s structure from weather and the elements.  Problems that can arise when neglecting siding over time include insect infestations, moisture, mold and mildew growth – all of which can have severe ramifications on your home’s underlying structure.

If you are considering refreshing your home’s siding, Modernize is here to help. This Siding Replacement Guide is designed to help homeowners understand different types of siding, the cost of each, the return on investment to expect from a siding replacement, and more. Continue reading to learn everything you need to know ahead of a home siding project.

siding

Siding Replacement Return on Investment

One of the many reasons homeowners seek out siding replacement projects is due to the high return on investment. In fact, siding replacements yield one of the highest R.O.I rates of any home improvement project, which makes them an especially practical investment when homeowners plan to resell.

The 2021 Cost vs. Value report indicates that stone veneer siding replacements are one of the most valuable home improvement project in terms of costs recovered during resale. And this is not just for home siding projects – stone veneer siding installations trump every other home improvement project in terms of potential recovered costs, besides garage door replacements.

Take a look at what to expect in 2022 in terms of return on investment, based on the type of siding installed on your home:

Type of Siding Estimated R.O.I.
Vinyl 80%
Wood 77%
Stucco 70% to 75%
Stone Veneer 92%
Natural Stone 60% to 70%
Aluminum 77%
Brick 65% to 75%
Fiber Cement 69%

When is it Time to Replace Siding?

Every Spring, homeowners around the country begin home siding projects to improve their home’s appearance and curb appeal:

“Spring is the best time to complete a siding project, as you don’t want your siding to suddenly expand, shrink or become brittle due to extreme heat or cold. There’s no better way to prevent this from happening than to do the job during the spring season, where the temperature is at its sweet spot!”

-Laura Adamson, Marketing Director at Aspen Home Improvements, Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

Beyond improving the curb appeal of your home and adding home value, there are times when siding replacements are crucial. Critical siding issues can not only compromise the structural security of your home, but your health and safety as well.

Here are 6 major signs that indicate your home requires a siding replacement:

1. Rotting

If you have wood siding, look for brittle sections that have begun to crumble or are on the verge of crumbling. You will notice these sections typically look dull compared to siding in better condition. This is a sign that moisture has begun to penetrate your siding, breaking down the properties that give wood its strength. Lightly tap on the areas of your siding that you suspect of having dry rot. This will allow you to identify a dry rotted area as only the outer layer of siding will remain intact. Untreated, rot will lead to further decay.

2. Warping

Warped siding boards usually indicate a problem. Examine your home from multiple angles to check if there are portions of your siding that are no longer flat compared to adjacent panels. This is a sign that serious damage, including rot, may be present beneath the surface. Use a screwdriver or awe to poke the surface area and beneath the siding to determine the condition of the material and substrate. If the siding material or substrate feels soft or cracks easily, it is a sure sign that it is time to replace the siding.

3. Cracking

Visible cracks on any siding material create an entry points for moisture and pests. You may want to consult a professional to inspect the depth and severity of your cracks to determine whether patchwork will suffice or if total siding replacement is necessary.

4. Holes from insects or birds

It can be difficult to spot small insect-caused holes in your siding, but if you encounter a series of carved patterns or see insects moving in and out of a small opening, you may have a more significant problem. Look for holes from birds much higher from the ground.

5. Unexpectedly High Energy Bills

A surge in your monthly utility bills may indicate that air is passing through your home. Check your windows and exterior door frames. If you don’t find leaks there, your siding is the most likely culprit. To resolve this issue moving forward, look into installing energy-efficient siding when doing your replacement.

6. Interior moisture

If you find traces of moisture, mold, or mildew inside of your house, be sure to investigate the condition in the same area on the exterior. Mold or mildew growth on interior walls adjacent to exterior walls could be an indication of excess moisture seeping in through compromised siding. In addition, peeling paint, sagging wallpaper, and soft or crumbling drywall could also point to a moisture problem resulting from compromised exterior siding. You may need to update your home’s insulation as well as the siding.

House Siding Options

These days, there are many types of siding materials to choose from for homes. Different types of siding vary in what they offer to your home, including factors like:

  • Structure and durability
  • Weather resistance
  • Appearance
  • Cost per square foot
  • Return on investment
  • Maintenance and upkeep needs

The most common siding options used for residential homes include the following types:

  • Vinyl siding
  • Fiber cement siding
  • Hardie board siding
  • Natural wood siding
  • Engineered wood siding
  • Brick siding
  • Natural stone siding
  • Stone veneer (aka faux stone) siding
  • Stucco siding
  • Aluminum siding

Best Types of Home Siding

Explore the pros and cons, average costs, and weather resistance of each popular type of siding

Take Me There

Choosing Siding Colors

Once you know which type of siding you want to go with, you can begin to pick out a color. Choosing siding colors can be one of the most enjoyable aspects of a siding replacement. While you may be drawn to a siding color right away, it’s helpful to use the following tips and steps to navigate the process:

  1. Determine your siding type. You may be limited on siding color options based on the type of siding. For instance, brick and wood allow for fewer color options, while vinyl color options are almost endless.
  2. Consider your home’s style. Home style is often a helpful indicator in which siding colors will work best. For instance, colonial homes work best with white, gray, and subtle colors. Victorian style homes better support bold colors and textures.
  3. Look at your front door, windows, and roof. It’s a good idea to choose a siding color that goes well with other exterior elements. For instance, you can contrast a dark front door or roof with a lighter colored siding, and vice versa. Keep in mind that you can always replace your door affordably to better suit your new siding replacement.
  4. Explore other homes in your neighborhood. Walking around and taking a look at other homes in your area is a good way to get siding inspiration and color ideas. Perhaps there is a home that you admire and shares your home’s style and build. Even better – if there is a home for sale in your neighborhood, take a look at its value online. This information can potentially indicate whether a home’s siding is resulting in a higher resale value.

How Much Does it Cost to Replace Siding?

Before diving into a siding replacement project, you probably want an estimate of what it will cost. Although your siding contractor will measure how much siding your home needs and provide you with quotes, you can also achieve a rough estimate yourself.

buying guide siding

Here is a quick way to determine how many squares – one square represents 100 square feet- of siding you will need to purchase.

  • Measure and multiply the height times the width of all the rectangular sections of your home in feet to determine square footage. Do not subtract window and door openings to allow for waste.
  • Next, measure and multiply height and width of gable ends and any other triangular areas and divide the total by two.
  • Add all of the totals together and divide by 100.
  • The resulting sum will be the number of squares of siding you will need for your project.

Remember to thoughtfully consider quality and cost of each type of siding before finalizing your siding replacement plans. Your siding professional will also be able to guide you on the best type of siding for your budget, style preferences, geographical location and climate.

Be sure to consult Modernize’s handy Siding Cost Calculator to get an accurate estimate of what your siding replacement project will cost you, based on your specifications.

Siding Replacement Cost Calculator

Take Me There

Hiring a Siding Replacement Contractor

Because a siding installation is labor intensive, you will likely require a licensed contractor to perform the job. It is to your advantage to select a reputable contractor who is highly experienced with siding installation. A licensed siding contractor will also have the necessary insurance to cover the installation, materials, and labor. Our siding contractor checklist can help you ensure you are hiring the right professional for the job. Here are a few tips to help you navigate the hiring process:

  1. For any contractor you contact, request a written estimate that includes all costs involved. This includes removal and disposal of old siding, and other job-related debris. All estimates should be signed and dated. To eliminate confusion regarding contract details, clearly note the scope of the work, the contractor’s warranty, and how long the warranty is in effect.
  2. Check with any local government office that has information about licensed contractors as well as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) for contractors regarding past or present complaints. Be sure to hire a contractor with positive reviews and years of experience doing siding replacements
  3. Evaluate quotes from three to four contractors. Consider both cost and quality in your assessment. Keep in mind that you can negotiate cost in some instances.

Looking for a place to start comparing contractors and project estimates? Modernize is your go-to resource. Our network of siding contractors are highly experienced and qualified to get the job done.

Maintaining Your New Siding

Proper care and maintenance of your new siding will help to extend its useful lifespan, as well as avoid additional damage to your home should it fail. Periodic cleaning and inspection will help you identify areas that may need attention. Remember that different types of siding require different maintenance and cleaning methods. Consult our siding cleaning and maintenance guide to learn how to best upkeep your home’s siding.

Simple caulking and painting, especially in high moisture climates, could save you hundreds of dollars in structural repairs.