Bathtub vs. Shower: Which Is Best for Your Remodel?

The bathroom is not just a functional space; it’s a sanctuary where one can relax and rejuvenate. As you embark on your bathroom remodeling journey, one pivotal decision looms large: bathtub vs. shower. Should you go for a bathtub, a shower, or both? Dive into this guide as we explore the pros, cons, costs, and resale values of each. 

The Bathtub vs. Shower Conundrum: Which Fits Your Lifestyle?

When it comes to bathroom remodels, the age-old debate of bathtub vs. shower persists. Both options have their merits. Bathtubs provide a spa-like escape, ideal for relaxation after a long day, while showers are often celebrated for their efficiency and space-saving design. Understanding your daily routines, space constraints, and aesthetic preferences can guide you in making a choice that harmonizes with your lifestyle and home design.

Bathtub: The Timeless Classic

Whether you have young kids at home or just love the appeal of a hot bath, there are plenty of reasons to love having a tub. But are the drawbacks worth the advantages? Let’s take a look. 

Pros of Having a Bathtub

1. Relaxation haven: A bathtub offers a spa-like experience. It’s perfect for unwinding with a glass of wine, a good book, or simply soaking away the stresses of the day.
2. Family-friendly: Bathtubs are ideal for families with young children, making bath time easier and more fun.
3. Versatility: With a showerhead installed over a tub, you can have the best of both worlds.

Cons of Having a Bathtub

1. Space hog: Bathtubs, especially the larger or freestanding types, can take up considerable space.
2. Maintenance: Bathtubs can be harder to clean, especially in hard-to-reach areas.
3. Accessibility issues: For the elderly or those with mobility issues, getting in and out of a tub can be challenging and potentially hazardous.

What Does a Tub Cost and What Is Having One Worth?

Your decision may ultimately come down to the project cost and how much of it you can recoup during resale. 

Average cost: Costs can range from $400 for basic alcove tubs to over $10,000 for luxurious freestanding variants. Installation and plumbing can add to this cost. 

Resale value: While many buyers appreciate a bathtub (especially in the master bath), the universal appeal is waning somewhat, influenced by changing preferences and lifestyles. 

Shower: The Modern Refresh

Having the right shower can make a huge difference to your daily routine. But are the water-saving, space-saving benefits enough to give up a bathtub? 

• Pros

  • Space-saver
  • Efficiency
  • Customization

• Cons

  • Limited relaxation
  • Potential for leaks
  • Accessibility Issues

Pros of Having a Shower

1. Space-saver: Showers, especially corner units, can fit snugly into tight bathroom spaces.
2. Efficiency: Showers use less water than baths, especially if you opt for water-saving showerheads.
3. Customization: Modern showers can be tailored to fit any aesthetic or function, from rain showers to steam features and bench seating.

Cons of Having a Shower

1. Limited relaxation: While some love the brisk efficiency of showers, they don’t offer the deep relaxation of a long soak.
2. Potential for leaks: Without proper installation and maintenance, showers can become a source of leaks.
3. Accessibility Issues: For some individuals, especially the elderly or those with mobility challenges, stepping in and out of a shower can pose a risk of slips and falls.

What Does a Shower Cost and What Is Having One Worth?

Average cost: Depending on the type and features, shower enclosures can range from $300 to $3,000. Luxury features and custom work can push the price higher. 

Resale value: A modern, high-end shower can be a huge selling point, especially in urban markets where speed and efficiency are paramount.  

Shower Remodel Cost Calculator

Take Me There

Is Your Lifestyle Better Suited to a Tub or Shower?

In the bathtub vs. shower debate, lifestyles, family dynamics, and personal preferences play a crucial role. Young professionals often lean towards showers due to their fast-paced lives. Families or those who view the bathroom as a relaxation hub might prefer bathtubs. Additionally, homeowners should consider the long-term, thinking about future needs and potential mobility issues. 

Bathtub vs. Shower: Why Not Both?

If you’re blessed with ample space and budget, incorporating both a bathtub and a shower can offer maximum flexibility. Here’s why: 

1. Versatility: Cater to all family members’ needs and preferences.
2. Higher resale value: Offering both options makes your home appealing to a broader range of potential buyers.
3. Design aesthetics: With the right design, a separate tub and shower can elevate the bathroom’s aesthetics, creating a luxurious spa-like atmosphere.

How to Make the Decision 

The bathtub vs. shower debate is deeply personal, influenced by budget, space, and homeowner preferences. Weigh the pros and cons, consider your lifestyle, and if possible, consult with a real estate expert to gauge potential impacts on resale value. Whether you choose to immerse yourself in a luxurious bath or indulge in a refreshing shower (or both!), ensure that your choice enhances both your daily life and your property’s value.