Skip to content
Ready to start your project? Enter your ZIP to find local pros.
Please enter a valid 5 digit zip code

5 Questions To Ask When Comparing Home Warranties

Are you doing a home improvement project?

Modernize can pair you with three to four pros in your area, so you can compare options and save time and money.

Get Started

Whether you’re buying a new home or preparing to sell, purchasing a home warranty is a common strategy to protect your investment by covering the cost to repair or replace major systems and appliances.

Once you understand the types of home warranties available—including systems, appliances, and combination coverage—you’ll need to compare home warranty options and decide on the best company that meets your needs.

The pros at Modernize can help connect with trusted companies in your area. But before you choose a provider, it’s important to understand what you should ask these businesses. In addition to knowing what warranty plans cover, here are five questions to consider when comparing and selecting a home warranty company:

1. How quickly are repairs completed?

One of the many conveniences of having a home warranty is the quick turnaround time to have a system or appliance repaired or replaced. Ask your potential home warranty company the average time it takes for service calls to be executed and work to be completed. 

Some repairs might be a higher priority than others. For example, a broken stove might be inconvenient, but a nonworking A/C system during summer can be unsafe. Ask the company if they have emergency services available and, if so, what qualifies as an emergency, what is the timeframe, and are there any additional costs accrued?

2. What is the homeowner responsible for?

Regardless of the home warranty company, homeowners are typically responsible for two costs: A yearly premium and service call fees.

  • Premiums are the base rate for having coverage and can range from $400–$600, on average. Most companies offer the option to pay over time with monthly payments.
  • Service fees are what you’ll pay when a claim is made and typically range from $75-$125. When inquiring about service fees, it’s important to know if you’ll be responsible for repeat fees—for example, if an HVAC system requires multiple repairs, how many service fees will be charged?

Home warranty companies might also require a home inspection or maintenance records before coverage can begin and likely require manufacturer maintenance plans be properly followed.

Understanding what is required of you will help you limit out-of-pocket expenses and save headaches when making a claim.

3. What are the limits and exclusions of the coverage?

As you compare your home warranty options, remember that even the best providers include certain exclusions and limitations. Understanding these before you sign a contract can help you avoid any surprise cost gaps that might arise when making a claim.

Home warranty exclusions are specific parts, items, or events that are not covered. For example, a warranty covering a home’s electrical system might not cover repairs to a security system’s wiring. While limits are the amount the company will pay up to for a specific item or for all claims within a set timeframe. Everything beyond these limits is the responsibility of the homeowner to pay.

4. Who are the company’s contractors?

It’s important to know that home warranty companies work with select local contractors and businesses to conduct service calls and complete the required repairs.

When selecting a home warranty company, you’ll want to know how their contractors are vetted and what local or state licenses and certifications they possess. You should also discuss any safety nets or procedures should you be unsatisfied with the work performed.

5. How do I terminate or transfer coverage?

If you’re looking to bring your home to market, or if you simply decide a home warranty is no longer necessary, knowing a company’s termination policy is vital. 

Most companies will allow you to transfer coverage to buyers for, as well as terminate an existing contract. Ask about any additional fees either of these scenarios could incur and the process for transferring in the event of sale. For sellers, it’s also worth knowing if you can renew early as an incentive to potential buyers. 

Next Steps

The pros at Modernize can work with you to understand your needs and quickly connect you with a trusted home warranty provider in your area. Buying a home or dealing with untimely repairs can be stressful. But selecting a home warranty company doesn’t have to be. Understanding the ins-and-outs of available plans and what different companies can offer you will help you select the best company to protect your investment.

Find the Right Contractor for Your Home Improvement Project

Whether you’re ready to begin your project now or need some expert advice, our network of contractors are here to help. With a few simple questions, we’ll find the best local professionals for you

Recommended Articles

Mother and daughter painting a wall together

Other Home Projects

Affordable Home Upgrades

We’ve all had that moment walking into a room thinking, “It’s fine, but…” Sometimes it’s dated hardware. Sometimes it’s lighting. Sometimes it’s just that nothing feels fresh anymore. Here’s the good news. You do not need a full renovation to fix it, and you do not need to tackle everything at once. The smarter approach…

This traditional, Victorian-style, wood-siding home is beautifully and tastefully decorated for the Holiday Season. Four evergreen trees are strung with lights in the front yard.

Other Home Projects

Professional Christmas Light Installation Cost

“The Quote was WHAT?!” My husband came downstairs this morning and met me in the kitchen to let me know that the contractors who’d installed a playset area earlier this week had informed him they install Christmas lights and asked if we wanted a quote. My husband agreed happily; who loves climbing up on the…

Small portable generator

Generators

Installing a Portable Backup Generator? Don’t Skip These Key Questions

Why Asking the Right Questions Matters Power outages happen — sometimes in the middle of a thunderstorm, sometimes on a perfectly sunny day thanks to grid issues. A portable backup generator can be a lifesaver, keeping essentials like your fridge, medical devices, or even just your Wi-Fi running. But before you grab the first one…

tax credits for insulation

Other Home Projects

How Tariffs Are Driving Up Home Renovation Costs

Why Tariffs Matter for Home Renovation Costs Home renovation projects across the U.S. can get more expensive in , and not just because of labor costs or inflation. A mix of ongoing and newly expanded tariffs on imported building materials continues to affect the price of common upgrades, from roofing and windows to plumbing, electrical…

Reviews from Real Homeowners

About Us

Welcome to Homeowner Resources! We are the Modernize blog. Modernize pairs more than 3 million homeowners a year with pre-vetted contractors in their area. This blog started because we believe homeowners should know everything about their homes, from how their HVAC works to which front door colors they might love. On Homeowner Resources, you can find information on every part of your home, right down to how you can negotiate with contractors to get the best price. Here's more about the blog.

Need a contractor? Learn more about how Modernize finds the right pro for you.