Enter your ZIP to
find local pros.
Please enter a valid 5 digit zip code

HVAC

York Furnace Review 2025: Balancing Budget, Efficiency & Comfort

Modernize Rating: 3/5

Average Cost: $2,300 - $10,000

Here’s a complete review of York furnaces, including the series types, pricing, customer satisfaction, and how York stacks up against other leading furnace brands.

Our Verdict: York is a reliable option for homeowners who want clear series choices and fair pricing. It’s a good fit for those who value a balance of comfort and affordability, but it may not be the right choice if you’re looking for the quietest or most premium systems available.

The Modernize Mission

Modernize maintains homeowner-first editorial integrity, meaning we accept no commissions and no partner links for this review. Our reviews are thoroughly fact-checked by our home improvement experts. Ratings are determined by a sophisticated algorithm to rate brands, including analyses of products, materials, quality, costs, sizes, durability, energy efficiency, and warranties.

Overview of York Furnaces

Established in 1874, York is one of the longest-standing HVAC manufacturers and is now part of Johnson Controls. The company has a strong U.S. presence, with products widely available through authorized dealers and installers.

York’s furnaces are offered in three series — Latitude, LX, and Affinity — spanning from basic 80% efficiency units to premium 98% AFUE condensing systems. This review focuses specifically on York gas furnaces, the most common heating choice for American homes.

York Furnace Fast Facts
Best ForTop TierCost InstalledStandout FeatureWarranty*
Tiered options and fair valueAffinity Series$2,300 to $10,000Variable-speed, modulating heat10 years parts; lifetime HX

*Lifetime heat exchanger with registration; 10 years parts warranty typical.

Why We Love York

At Modernize, we love York for its straightforward series structure. Homeowners can easily compare Latitude (budget), LX (mid-tier), and Affinity (premium), without wading through dozens of model numbers. We also appreciate York’s reputation for durability and value, giving homeowners dependable performance at a fair price.

We especially like that York offers up to 98% AFUE efficiency in its premium line, giving cold-climate homeowners the chance to cut fuel bills significantly, while still offering affordable 80% units for warmer states.

Pros and Cons of York Furnaces

It’s important to consider both the advantages and the limitations before making a decision.

Pros

  • Clear three-tier lineup (Latitude, LX, Affinity) for easy comparison
  • Efficiency up to 98% AFUE in premium models
  • Variable-speed and modulating technology available
  • Strong warranties with lifetime coverage on heat exchangers
  • Competitive pricing compared to brands like Carrier or Lennox

Cons

  • Entry-level Latitude furnaces are very basic single-stage systems
  • Premium Affinity models can still fall slightly short of the quietest brands
  • Quality of installation varies by dealer
  • Less consumer brand recognition compared to Carrier or Trane

What York Offers

York furnaces are available in different types of operation and efficiency levels, giving homeowners options that balance cost, comfort, and energy use. Understanding these types makes it easier to decide which furnace is the best fit for your home.

york furnace reviews

  • Single-Stage Furnaces: These furnaces operate at one fixed heating level. They are the most affordable and simplest to install but can create more noticeable temperature swings. Single-stage units are often best for smaller homes or milder climates.
  • Two-Stage Furnaces: Two-stage furnaces provide both a low and high heat setting. They typically run on the lower stage most of the time, which saves energy and keeps temperatures more consistent. When the weather gets colder, they automatically shift into high gear. This type is a strong balance of comfort and efficiency.
  • Modulating Furnaces: Modulating systems adjust heat output in small increments to match your home’s exact heating needs. They deliver the most even temperatures, the quietest operation, and the highest efficiency. While they cost more upfront, they are an excellent choice for large homes, cold climates, or homeowners planning to stay long-term.
  • 80% vs. 90%+ Efficiency Furnaces: York sells both non-condensing (80% AFUE) and condensing (90% to 98% AFUE) furnaces. An 80% unit is usually sufficient in warmer climates or where venting constraints exist, while a 90%+ furnace is the better option for cold regions where lower fuel costs and rebates justify the higher price.

Top York Furnaces

York continues to manufacture a lineup of furnaces that fit different efficiency and comfort needs. Here are some of the most popular options homeowners consider today:

York TM9V — Two-Stage, 96% AFUE

  • Features: Two-stage heating with a variable-speed blower for consistent comfort and quieter performance.
  • Pros: Great balance of price and efficiency, ENERGY STAR® certified.
  • Cons: Higher upfront cost than single-stage models.
  • Additional Info: A popular mid-range option that suits average to colder climates.

York YP9C — Modulating, 98% AFUE

  • Features: Modulating gas valve and variable-speed blower deliver precise temperature control and maximum efficiency.
  • Pros: York’s top-of-the-line furnace, offering the quietest and most comfortable heating.
  • Cons: Premium price point.
  • Additional Info: Best for homeowners who plan to stay in their homes long-term and want the lowest fuel bills.

York TL9E — Single-Stage, 95% AFUE

  • Features: Basic single-stage performance with high-efficiency condensing design.
  • Pros: Affordable entry into high-efficiency furnaces.
  • Cons: Single-stage operation can lead to minor temperature swings.
  • Additional Info: Great budget-friendly replacement choice in colder regions.

York TG8S — Single-Stage, 80% AFUE

  • Features: Non-condensing furnace designed for milder climates or where venting limitations exist.
  • Pros: Lower upfront cost, straightforward performance.
  • Cons: Less efficient than condensing models; higher long-term fuel use.
  • Additional Info: Often chosen in the South or where code allows 80% AFUE systems.

Customer Reviews and Ratings

Customer feedback on York furnaces is mixed but generally positive. Homeowners often note the fair price point and long-term reliability, especially in LX and Affinity units. Positive comments highlight energy savings and solid warranties, while negatives typically mention that basic Latitude models are noisier and that installation quality makes a big difference in performance.

“York furnaces are pretty good. All furnaces now (at least in the US) come with a 10 year parts warranty and 20 years for the heat exchanger. That is whether you pay for the most expensive brand or something off brand. Most techs will tell you that the INSTALL is much more important than the actual equipment. So you need to make sure you have a quality company completing your install.”Reddit Review

“York is the major brand that we sell, so i’m probably biased. The TM9V is a really good furnace and I love the LX series of AC and heat pumps, much more than the York affinity. It is cheaper and I believe it’s a better system. You can match the 14.5 Seer outdoor unit with variable speed motor and txv to achieve almost 16 Seer. I think with the 3 ton it will match to 16 Seer and the others are 15.6+. We have installed many like this and have had no problems… knock on wood”HVAC Talk Review

“Customers correctly do their research after we quote them a York unit and see the old Consumer Reports customer satisfaction survey. In this survey, York is not ranked among the top brands. It frustrates me that people still use this old and unreliable information to judge the equipment.”Expert Review

How Much Do York Furnaces Cost?

York furnaces typically cost between $2,300 and $10,000 installed, depending on series, size, and job complexity. Entry-level Latitude units sit at the low end, while Affinity furnaces with modulating technology land at the higher end.

York Furnace Cost by Series

York Furnace Cost by Series
SeriesInstalled Cost RangeEfficiency (AFUE)
Latitude$2,300 to $5,40080% to 95%
LX$2,600 to $7,20080% to 97%
Affinity$3,500 to $10,00080% to 98%

York Furnace Cost by Model

York Furnace Cost by Model
York ModelEfficiency (AFUE)Type of OperationTypical Installed Cost
TG8S80%Single-Stage$2,300 to $4,500
TL9E95%Single-Stage$3,200 to $5,800
TM9V96%Two-Stage, Variable$4,000 to $7,200
YP9C98%Modulating, Variable$5,000 to $9,000+

York Furnace Cost by Home Size

York Furnace Cost by Home Size
Home SizeTypical CapacityInstalled Cost Range
1,200 sq ft40k to 60k BTU$2,300 to $4,900
2,000 sq ft60k to 80k BTU$3,000 to $6,200
3,000 sq ft80k to 100k BTU+$4,500 to $9,000+

York Furnace Cost by Region

York Furnace Cost by Region
RegionInstalled Cost RangeNotes
South$2,300 to $5,50080% AFUE units common in warm climates
Midwest$2,800 to $7,200Two-stage LX models popular
Northeast$3,500 to $10,000High demand for Affinity furnaces
West$2,600 to $7,800Mix of 80% and condensing units

Factors Influencing Cost

  • Efficiency level (AFUE rating)
  • Furnace staging (single, two-stage, modulating)
  • Capacity required based on home size
  • Installation complexity (ductwork, venting, or code upgrades)
  • Regional labor costs

Financing Options

York dealers often provide financing programs with monthly payments, along with rebate eligibility for ENERGY STAR® models in certain states.

HVAC Replacement Cost Calculator

Take Me There

How York Compares to Other Providers

When comparing top furnace brands, York holds its own against names like Rheem, Carrier, and Goodman. Here’s how it stacks up.

York vs. Rheem

  • Cost Range: Both $2,300 to $10,000
  • Pros: York has a simple tiered structure, Rheem offers excellent value on mid-tier units
  • Cons: York’s entry units are basic; Rheem’s lineup can be harder to navigate
  • What Sets York Apart: Straightforward choice between three series makes selection easier

Explore Our Rheem Furnace Review

York vs. Carrier

  • Cost Range: York $2,300 to $10,000, Carrier $2,400 to $8,000
  • Pros: York is competitively priced; Carrier has greater name recognition and dealer availability
  • Cons: York’s consumer profile is smaller; Carrier units may cost more in some regions
  • What Sets York Apart: Premium Affinity models reach up to 98% AFUE at fair pricing

Explore Our Carrier Furnace Review

York vs. Goodman

  • Cost Range: York $2,300 to $10,000, Goodman $2,100 to $6,300
  • Pros: York offers higher efficiency and comfort features; Goodman is the budget leader
  • Cons: York costs more upfront; Goodman furnaces may not last as long
  • What Sets York Apart: Better warranty coverage and longer-term reliability

Explore Our Goodman Furnace Review

Frequently Asked Questions About York Furnaces

Homeowners considering a York furnace often want to know about lifespan, costs, efficiency, and warranties. Below are the most common questions answered in detail.

How long does a York furnace last?

A York furnace typically lasts 15 to 20 years, with Affinity and LX models often performing longer when maintained with annual service.

How much does a York furnace cost?

Installed costs range from $2,300 to $10,000 depending on the series, size, and location. Latitude units sit at the low end, while Affinity furnaces reach the top range.

Are York furnaces energy efficient?

Yes. York furnaces range from 80% AFUE in entry-level models up to 98% AFUE in Affinity units, making them competitive with other major brands.

Should I choose Latitude, LX, or Affinity?

  • Latitude: Best for mild climates or homeowners on a budget.
  • LX: Mid-tier option with two-stage heating for balanced comfort.
  • Affinity: Premium choice with modulating technology, ideal for colder regions and long-term investment.

Do York furnaces qualify for rebates?

Yes. High-efficiency York furnaces (90% AFUE and above) often qualify for utility rebates, tax credits, or state energy programs.

Are York furnaces backed by warranties?

Yes. Most York furnaces come with a 10-year parts warranty and a lifetime or 20-year heat exchanger warranty with registration. Extended YORKCare plans are also available.

Furnace Replacement New York City

Final Verdict: Should You Choose York?

York furnaces are a dependable option for homeowners who want clear choices, fair pricing, and efficiency options for every climate. While they may not always offer the quietest performance or the prestige of larger brands, their Affinity line delivers top efficiency, and their Latitude and LX series provide affordable alternatives. For a balanced mix of cost, comfort, and coverage, York furnaces remain a strong contender in 2025.

Explore More on HVAC

Looking for more than just one review? The Modernize Review Hub brings together detailed insights on AC, furnace, and heat pump brands, installers, and products all in one place. It’s the easiest way to compare your options side by side and get a clearer picture of what will work best for your home.

Share this article