Master Bathtub Resale Value: Should You Replace It with a Shower?

The bathroom, for many homeowners, is a sanctuary of solace and relaxation. But when it comes to making the decision between a shower or a bathtub, it’s a conundrum that can throw many into a quandary. Even more pressing for homeowners is the potential impact of this decision on their property’s resale value. Bathtub vs. shower for resale: Does it matter?

If you’re one of those homeowners contemplating removing the master bathtub from your primary bathroom to make way for a sleek shower, read on. This article is for you! 

Why Are Master Bathtubs Such a Big Deal Anyway?

Historically, bathtubs were a luxury item, a mark of prestige. Over time, as they became more common, they were seen as a standard feature, especially in the primary or master bathroom. Families with children or those who simply love a good soak once in a while find a bathtub indispensable. 

For some potential buyers, especially those with young children, a bathtub might be a non-negotiable. For others, especially urbanites or younger couples, a stylish walk-in shower might be the preference. 

The Resale Value Debate

The truth is, while many homebuyers love the luxury of a master bathtub, others are leaning towards the practicality and modern aesthetics of a spacious walk-in shower. If you’re considering a bathroom remodel, here’s what you need to know about the resale value implications: 

Demographics Matter

Who’s most likely to buy your home when you sell? Families with young children may prioritize bathtubs, while urban professionals might prefer a high-end shower. 

Space and Layout

Sometimes, the decision is more about space optimization. If your bathroom feels cramped, replacing a seldom-used tub with a shower can make the space feel more open and usable. 

Luxury Showers Can Be a Selling Point

Modern, luxury walk-in showers with features like rain showerheads, bench seating, and frameless doors can be just as much a selling point as a master bathtub for certain buyers. 

Questions to Ponder Before You Renovate

If you’re on the fence, here are some key questions to guide your decision: 

1. How Long Do You Plan to Stay? If you’re in your forever home and you’re certain that a shower would improve your quality of life, then go for it! However, if you plan to sell in a few years, consider the potential buyers in your area. 
2. What Do Other Homes in Your Area Feature? If most homes in your neighborhood have maintained their bathtubs and you’re one of the few without, this might be a detractor for some buyers. 
3. Can You Compromise with a Shower-Tub Combo? This is a great way to maximize space while catering to both shower-lovers and bath enthusiasts. 
4. Have You Consulted a Real Estate Expert? An experienced realtor can provide insight into the preferences of buyers in your specific area. 

Bathroom Remodel Cost Calculator

Take Me There

Should I Keep the Master Bathtub in My Primary Bathroom for Resale Value?

The shower vs. bathtub debate isn’t one-size-fits-all. While there’s no definitive answer, the key is to make an informed decision that suits both your current needs and future considerations.  

Remember, a bathroom remodel can be one of the best investments in your home, but only if done thoughtfully. Whether you go for a luxurious soak or a refreshing splash, ensure it adds value to both your daily routine and your property’s worth.