Enter your zip to
find local pros.
Please enter a valid 5 digit zip code

Roofing

Erie Home Review 2024

Modernize Rating: 4/5

Average Cost: $14,000 - $28,000

Erie Home operates in 35 states, bringing roofing expertise to the table, as well as a strong warranty on all their metal roofing products, which typically range from $14,000 to $28,000 for a standard-sized home. In some areas, they also handle basement waterproofing and repair, foundation repair, and siding.

The Modernize Mission

Modernize maintains homeowner-first editorial integrity, meaning we accept no commissions and no partner links for this review. Our reviews are thoroughly fact-checked by our home improvement experts. Ratings are determined by a sophisticated algorithm to rate brands, including analyses of products, materials, quality, costs, sizes, durability, energy efficiency, and warranties.

Erie Home has specialized in roofing projects since its start in 1976. Erie Home claims to have served over 100,000 customers in that time, making them an experienced leader in the industry. The company operates in 35 states in the East, South, and Midwest. Explore our Erie Home review to learn more about their services and customer experiences.

It’s important to note that Erie Home actually has numerous names, including Erie Construction or Erie Metal Roofs. On some websites and in some areas, it’s known simply as Erie. To be sure of what company you’re working with, always go to the website and look for the home company name.

Erie Home Logo

Pros and Cons of Erie Home

As with all other construction or renovation companies, there are pros and cons to Erie Home. Here’s what you need to know before you dive into work with Erie Home.

  • Pros

    • Flexible Financial Plans
    • Warranties
    • Exceptional Strength
  • Cons

    • Pricing Is Rather Steep
    • High-Pressure Sales Tactics
    • Lack of Support for Some Materials

Pros

  • Flexible Financial Plans. By working with a variety of partners, Erie Home ensures there is “something for everyone” who needs financing to get the work done.
  • Erie Home provides a comprehensive, limited lifetime warranty on all metal roofs.
  • Exceptional Strength. The roofs installed by Erie Home are among the safest on the market, with a class 3 or 4 impact rating and up to 120 mph of wind resistance. This is ideal for those homes in the middle of tornado alley or those in areas prone to hurricanes and severe weather.

Cons

  • Pricing Is Rather Steep. When held up against the competition, most customers have found that Erie Home is the more expensive option. This is why it’s important to get several quotes and ask Erie Home why they are the best option for your particular situation.
  • High-Pressure Sales Tactics. Many customers have complained about Erie Home’s powerful sales tactics, which often leave a homeowner feeling pressured to sign right away.
  • Lack of Support for Some Materials. The support for those with metal roofs is quite robust after the sale and installation; for other types of materials, not so much.

What Types of Projects Does Erie Home Perform?

Metal roofing is the bread-and-butter for Erie Home. Though there might be other metal materials available in your regional area, here are the big three to expect when you contact Erie for a quote.

Metal Shake Roofing

This unique look brings resistance to fire, rot, and other weather damage. It looks just like much more expensive wood shakes without the trouble of serious maintenance.

stone coated slate metal roof

Metal Spanish Tile

These tiles look like traditional clay barrel tiles but stand up to weather conditions with much more aplomb. They don’t crack, break, or absorb moisture.

Metal tile-look roof

Metal Architectural Shingles

These look like high-end asphalt shingles but last three times as long. They also come in numerous colors and resist the fading of UV light.

Black metal roof on a new build

Some Erie Home areas provide asphalt roofing as well, but this isn’t nearly as common as their metal options.

All metal roofing materials come with a limited lifetime warranty that spans 50 years. This is one of the best warranties you can find through any remodeling company, so that alone might make Erie Home worth the higher price.

One of the reasons they can offer this warranty is the durability of the roofing products: They have either class 3 or 4 impact resistance, which means they can withstand hail and debris during severe storms. They also resist freezing and thawing cycles, splitting, and cracking.

Erie Home also offers other services, but the availability of these depends upon location. In some areas, for instance, air quality control options are available for the whole home. Basements and foundations are also a strong suit for Erie Home, but these are available only in select service areas. Siding is also an option for some homeowners.

How Much Does Erie Home Cost?

It’s unusual to be able to provide a price range for services from home remodeling or renovation companies, and the reason is simple: Every job is different. So, though you won’t find pricing on the website for Erie Home, what you might find is the cost of materials. While the company doesn’t provide exact numbers without a formal quote, the national average is around $7 to $12 per square foot.

This price range reflects the durability and longevity of metal roofing, which can last significantly longer than traditional asphalt shingles and provide excellent resistance to weather and environmental damage. Consequently, Erie Home’s metal roofing solutions typically result in higher total costs, ranging from $14,000 to $28,000 for a standard-sized home, due to the enhanced durability and aesthetic appeal of metal roofing.

When calculating the cost of installation, Erie Home considers several factors: the price of the material itself, how much of it you need, the style and pitch of the roof, the cost to remove the old roofing, shipping of the materials, and finally, the labor cost.

Factors Affecting Cost of Erie Home Projects

The factors that affect your costs are wide and varied. Some are within your control, while others are not. Here’s what helps create your bottom line.

  • Materials Used: When it comes to roofing, you always have a choice in materials. Though Erie Home carries a limited line of products for roofs, the warranty is robust, and the metal stands up to the harshest weather. You can choose the material that best suits your budget, but that might not be the best for your particular aesthetic. That’s where a little wiggle room in your budget comes in very handy.
  • The Scope of the Project: This includes the size of your roof, the complexity of it, the slope of the roof, and the little “extras” you might need to finish the job, such as new gutters. With a basement or foundation repair, the cost of the work depends upon just how bad the problem is — something that’s usually impossible to determine without the help of an expert inspection.
  • Little Surprises: Sometimes nasty little surprises pop up that threaten to ruin your budget. For instance, if your previous roofing must be removed and the contractors discover wood rot underneath, you will have to get that repaired before the work can continue. The same is true with basement work — it’s entirely possible for a contractor to give a good-faith quote and then find something else wrong as they get deeper into the work. Adding 10% to your overall budget to cover these contingencies is always a good idea.
  • Geographical Location: Where you are in the country makes a difference in your bottom line. Just as groceries and household products cost more in one area of the country than another, the same is true with local labor costs, shipping, and the like. Look into the average cost of materials and labor in your area to get a rough idea of what your costs might run.
  • In-Season or Off-Season: When you choose Erie Home to handle your roofing needs, pay attention to the time of year. Many companies are incredibly busy during the summer, when there are fewer holidays, the weather is really nice, and the kids are out of school, so it’s easier to get away from home for a few days for the work to be done. But if you don’t mind having the work done during the fall or winter months, you might be able to save on the costs of labor.

Expect an in-home consultation to take up to three hours, during which the Erie Home representative will explain your pricing and leave you with a comprehensive, free quote. The company offers financing through numerous partners that can help ensure you find a plan that fits your budget. It also offers ongoing discounts up-front that can reduce your bottom line before any financing is applied.

Benefits of Investing in Erie Home

One of the biggest benefits of Erie Home is the 50-year limited lifetime warranty on all metal roofing products. The warranty covers repairs of the roof and full replacement if necessary, protecting against wind damage, large hail, fire, and more. Excessive aging and weathering of the surface coating is also included in the warranty, which is a rarity these days. That warranty is transferable to a new homeowner, so that can potentially boost your sale price if you choose to sell.

To be able to provide that warranty, Erie Home also has to provide exceptional materials for their products that can truly stand the test of time, as well as the skilled labor necessary to ensure that those products are installed properly and safely. Erie Home has a reputation among customers for very knowledgeable contractors who can explain the process along the way and ensure the job is done right the first time.

Erie Home vs. Its Competitors

The top competitors for Erie Home will depend upon the location. For instance, a home improvement or renovation company might work in only a few states where Erie provides service and lead to competition in that local market, but not competition for the entire company.

That being said, some of the biggest competitors making waves against Erie Home include Apple Roofing, Erdo, and Alpha Omega Construction Group. None of these competitors are transparent with pricing, which makes sense considering that it’s tough to provide an idea of prices when every home is so different.

The reviews and ratings of each company tend to be about the same, with Erie Home edging slightly ahead as a better option for longevity. The warranty for Erie Home is mentioned in many reviews, but so are the high-pressure sales tactics. Those high-pressure tactics seem to have eased in recent years for Erie Home but not necessarily for the competition, so if you’re looking for a company that allows you to make a decision on your own time, Erie Home might be the best option for you.

Is Erie Home Right for Me?

Erie Home could work well for you if you live in one of the states the company serves. Keep in mind that while roofing is available through all Erie Home franchises, some might not offer basement waterproofing or foundation repair, and even fewer will provide siding options. If you want a metal roof that offers an extended warranty on materials and workmanship, choosing Erie Home could be your best bet.

Compare top-rated roofing pros in your area.

Read real homeowner reviews, explore qualifications, and view promotions. Modernize makes it easy to browse professionals and find one that will be perfect for your project.