Enter your ZIP to
find local pros.
Please enter a valid 5 digit zip code

Roofing

GAF Shingles Review 2025: Durable Style at a Fair Price

Modernize Rating: 5/5

Average Cost: $5 - $9

Here’s an in-depth review of GAF shingles, including product lines, pricing, warranties, real-world considerations, and how GAF compares to other major shingle brands.
Our Verdict: GAF is a top choice for architectural asphalt shingles thanks to broad color options, strong wind and algae protections, and tiered warranties through certified installers. Homeowners chasing ultra-premium aesthetics or the most robust manufacturer workmanship coverage may also compare CertainTeed and Owens Corning before deciding.

The Modernize Mission

Modernize maintains homeowner-first editorial integrity, meaning we accept no commissions and no partner links for this review. Our reviews are thoroughly fact-checked by our home improvement experts. Ratings are determined by a sophisticated algorithm to rate brands, including analyses of products, materials, quality, costs, sizes, durability, energy efficiency, and warranties.

Overview of GAF

This GAF shingles review looks at North America’s largest roofing and waterproofing manufacturer, founded in 1886 and headquartered in New Jersey. GAF manufactures residential and commercial roofing products and distributes nationally through pro channels and big-box retailers, with installations performed by independent contractors.

GAF’s residential lineup centers on architectural (laminated) asphalt shingles like Timberline HDZ and UHDZ, with algae-resistant technology, enhanced nailing zones, and wind warranties when installed as part of a qualifying system.

GAF Fast Facts
Best ForTop ModelCost InstalledStandout FeatureWarranty
Most homeowners wanting style + valueTimberline HDZ architectural shinglesAbout $6.00 to $9.00 per sq ft installed (regional variance)WindProven limited wind warranty with qualifying system; StainGuard Plus algae protectionLimited lifetime shingle warranty when properly specified

Why We Love GAF

We like GAF’s balance of curb appeal, tested performance, and clear warranty tiers. The StrikeZone/LayerLock nailing design and DuraGrip adhesive help crews hit target fasteners and deliver rated wind performance, while StainGuard Plus combats blue-green algae in humid regions. Taken together with wide color lines and a huge installer network, GAF is an easy brand to spec for most homes.

Pros and Cons of GAF

Before you choose a shingle brand, it helps to balance benefits and trade-offs.

GAF Pros

  • Strong Wind + Algae Protections: WindProven limited wind warranty with qualifying accessories and 25-year StainGuard Plus algae protection on labeled products.
  • Installer Ecosystem: Access to System Plus, Silver Pledge, and Golden Pledge warranties through certified contractors.
  • Broad Selection: Multiple Timberline lines, colors, and regional stock keep lead times reasonable.

GAF Cons

  • Warranty Tiers Depend on Contractor Status: Top-tier Golden Pledge workmanship coverage is only available via Master Elite contractors.
  • Premium Looks May Cost More: UHDZ and designer lines price near CertainTeed’s upscale options.

What GAF Offers

GAF manufactures a full range of residential asphalt shingles, from budget-friendly 3-tab styles to popular architectural designs and upscale premium options. These shingles are engineered for durability, weather resistance, and long-lasting curb appeal, with features that address common homeowner concerns like wind damage, algae staining, and installation efficiency.

Colorful House Roof Shingles Samples on Display

In addition to shingles, GAF produces a complete roofing accessory system — including underlayments, starter strips, ridge caps, leak barriers, and ventilation components — designed to work together for optimal performance and to qualify for enhanced warranty coverage.

Top Products From GAF

  1. Timberline HDZ
    • Key features: LayerLock + StrikeZone nailing, DuraGrip adhesive, StainGuard Plus on labeled colors.
    • Why it stands out: Best all-around value and color range; widely stocked.
  2. Timberline UHDZ (Ultra HDZ)
    • Key features: Thicker profile, enhanced shadow lines for a designer look.
    • Why it stands out: Upscale curb appeal without jumping to designer shingles.
  3. Royal Sovereign (3-Tab)
    • Key features: Lightweight, budget-friendly; basic warranty terms.
    • Why it stands out: Lowest upfront cost for rentals and simple rooflines.
  4. System Warranties (via Certified Contractors)
    • Options: System Plus, Silver Pledge, Golden Pledge (tiered materials + workmanship).
    • Why it stands out: Scalable protection including workmanship coverage up to 20 to 30 years depending on shingle and program.

Customer Reviews and Ratings

Homeowners and pros routinely call out GAF’s broad color selection, straightforward installs, and strong algae and wind protections. Some feedback notes that premium lines carry higher prices and that warranty terms require specific accessory sets and certified installers. Some reviews also mention concerns about long-term shingle stability in extreme weather and challenges navigating warranty claims. Even so, ratings across trade and homeowner platforms generally reflect solid reliability for the money.

“We LOVE Our GAF Timberline UHDZ Roofing Shingles, They Look GREAT On Our Ranch Home. We Would HIGHLY Recommend This Product For Your Home” BBB Review

“GAF HDZ Shingles are amazing. Im not sure where you are located but they have one of the highest wind rating in that class of shingles. Leave the UHD ones alone you dont need them. Make sure the contractor uses premium ridge caps. Do not let them cut up 3tab shingles for your ridge. These should not be any additional cost.”Roofing Talk Review

“We bought our house knowing we would need a new roof. We just replaced it and it looks great and definitely make the appearance of our house look new. We couldn’t be happier with the final product.”Site Review

How Much Do GAF Shingles Cost?

GAF pricing varies by region, roof size and complexity, tear-off needs, and the shingle line you choose. Architectural installs commonly land around $6.00 to $9.00 per square foot, with low-cost markets dipping near $5.00 to $6.00 and high-cost metros reaching $9.00 to $11.00. Removing old roofing can add $1.00 to $4.00 per sq ft. For a typical 2,000 sq ft roof, expect $12,000 to $18,000+ for Timberline HDZ, with UHDZ trending higher.

Example Project Estimates

  • Chicago, IL (2,000 sq ft, Timberline HDZ): $14,000 to $19,000 including tear-off, underlayment, and ridge vent.
  • Dallas–Fort Worth, TX (2,000 sq ft, Timberline HDZ): $12,000 to $16,000; moderate labor, strong contractor availability.
  • San Diego, CA (2,000 sq ft, Timberline UHDZ): $17,000 to $22,000 due to higher labor and disposal costs.

GAF Cost by Product Line

GAF Cost by Product Line
GAF LineLow-Cost AreasAverage MarketsHigh-Cost Metros
Royal Sovereign (3-tab)$4.50 to $6.00/sq ft$5.50 to $7.00/sq ft$7.00 to $8.50/sq ft
Timberline HDZ (architectural)$5.50 to $7.50/sq ft$6.00 to $9.00/sq ft$9.00 to $11.00/sq ft
Timberline UHDZ (premium arch.)$6.50 to $8.50/sq ft$7.50 to $10.00/sq ft$10.00 to $12.00/sq ft

GAF Cost by Region

GAF Cost by Region
RegionTypical Total (Architectural, 2,000 sq ft Roof)
Northeast$16,000 to $22,000
Midwest$12,500 to $17,500
South$12,000 to $17,000
West$15,000 to $22,000

GAF Cost by Roof Size

GAF Cost by Roof Size
Roof AreaTypical Installed Total (Architectural Shingles)
1,500 sq ft$9,000 to $13,500
2,000 sq ft$12,000 to $18,000
2,500 sq ft$15,000 to $22,500
3,000 sq ft$18,000 to $27,000

GAF Cost by State

GAF Cost by State
StateTypical Total (Architectural, 2,000 sq ft Roof)
California$17,000 to $22,000
Texas$12,000 to $16,500
Florida$13,000 to $17,500
New York$16,500 to $21,500
Illinois$14,000 to $19,000
Ohio$12,500 to $17,000
Georgia$12,500 to $17,000
Pennsylvania$15,000 to $20,000
Arizona$13,500 to $18,500
Washington$15,500 to $20,500

Factors Influencing Cost

  • Roof size, pitch, and story height
  • Tear-off and disposal requirements
  • Accessory system choices (leak barrier, deck protection, ridge cap, ventilation)
  • Market labor rates and permit fees
  • Shingle line and color availability (HDZ vs. UHDZ)

Financing Options

GAF does not finance directly, but many GAF-factory certified contractors offer financing through partner lenders, often with low- or no-interest promotional terms. Always compare contractor financing to HELOC or bank options to minimize total borrowing costs.

Roof Replacement Cost Calculator

Take Me There

How GAF Compares to Other Providers

When shopping for a new roof, many homeowners compare GAF to other top shingle brands to find the right balance of durability, style, and cost. GAF often stands out for its combination of broad color choices, competitive pricing, and an extensive certified contractor network. Below, we compare GAF to three other well-known manufacturers to help you decide which might be the best fit for your home.

Owens Corning vs. GAF

  • Cost Range: Similar architectural-grade pricing in most markets.
  • Pros (Owens Corning): SureNail strip and long track record for nailing accuracy and wind hold.
  • Cons (Owens Corning): Availability and colors vary by region.
  • Why GAF Stands Out: Offers WindProven limited wind warranty with a full system and strong algae coverage on StainGuard Plus-labeled shingles.

CertainTeed vs. GAF

  • Cost Range: CertainTeed Landmark often prices at or above Timberline HDZ in many metros.
  • Pros (CertainTeed): Premium aesthetics and heavy, designer-grade options; robust warranties.
  • Cons (CertainTeed): Higher material cost on many SKUs.
  • Why GAF Stands Out: Broader stocking and competitive price-to-performance in mainstream architectural lines.

TAMKO vs. GAF

  • Cost Range: TAMKO often competes at value price points.
  • Pros (TAMKO): Attractive colorways and competitive pricing.
  • Cons (TAMKO): Warranty and pro-network breadth vary by region.
  • Why GAF Stands Out: Depth of certified-installer network and access to high-tier Golden Pledge workmanship coverage via Master Elite contractors.

Frequently Asked Questions About GAF Shingles

When evaluating roofing options, homeowners often have questions about performance, warranties, installation, and costs. Below, we answer some of the most common topics people search for when considering GAF, covering everything from durability and weather protection to who installs GAF roofing and how to get the most from your warranty.

Two men on a roof in safety gear

How long do GAF architectural shingles last?

Most Timberline architectural shingles carry a limited lifetime shingle warranty when properly specified. In real-world conditions, homeowners can generally expect 25 to 30 years of service life, though this can vary based on climate, installation quality, ventilation, and ongoing maintenance.

What is GAF’s WindProven warranty?

With a qualifying combination of GAF accessories installed as a system, eligible Timberline HDZ shingles can receive a WindProven limited wind warranty. This requires specific starter, deck protection, ridge cap, and related components.

Does GAF protect against roof algae?

Yes. StainGuard Plus technology on labeled shingles provides a 25-year limited algae-discoloration warranty against blue-green algae.

What are the major GAF warranty tiers?

System Plus focuses on product coverage, Silver Pledge adds workmanship coverage, and Golden Pledge offers the most comprehensive materials and workmanship protection through Master Elite contractors.

Can I finance a GAF roof?

GAF itself doesn’t finance projects, but many GAF-certified contractors offer financing through partner lenders. Compare terms with HELOC or bank loans to find the best rate.

Who Installs GAF Roofing?

GAF shingles are installed by a range of professionals: from trusted local contractors familiar with regional codes, to regional chains offering broader coverage, and large national home remodelers and roofing companies. Well-known companies that frequently install GAF products include Power Home Remodeling (a GAF Master Elite contractor serving multiple states), DaBella (also Master Elite, recognized for high warranties), and Elite Construction & Roofing (GAF Certified, offering system warranty eligibility). For full warranty access, aim to hire a GAF Master Elite or GAF Certified Contractor in your area.

Final Verdict: Are GAF Shingles Right for Me?

GAF is a strong choice for homeowners seeking architectural asphalt shingles that balance durability, style, and value. With wide color options, solid wind and algae protections, and flexible warranty tiers backed by certified contractors, it’s a brand that performs well in most regions.

If you’re after ultra-premium aesthetics or the longest possible workmanship coverage regardless of installer network, it’s worth comparing CertainTeed and Owens Corning before deciding. Ultimately, the best fit will come down to which brand offers the look, warranty, and price that align with your home and budget.

Compare top-rated roofing pros in your area.

Read real homeowner reviews, explore qualifications, and view promotions. Modernize makes it easy to browse professionals and find one that will be perfect for your project.

Share this article