Skip to content
Ready to start your project? Enter your ZIP to find local pros.
Please enter a valid 5 digit zip code

3 Things to Consider Before a Metal Roof Replacement

Considering a metal roof for your home? Before you commit to a metal roof replacement, it is important to understand the advantages and disadvantages of this unique roofing type.

Are you doing a Roofing project?

Modernize can pair you with three to four pros in your area, so you can compare options and save time and money.

Get Started

Replacing your roof is a major investment that requires careful research, budgeting, and consideration. Before you commit to a metal roof replacement, it is important to understand the advantages and disadvantages of this unique roofing type.

Compare Roof Replacement Costs

Metal roofing materials can be three times as expensive as other traditional roofing types —  like asphalt, wood, foam, or rubber. The cost of metal roofing materials can range from $7 to $9 per square foot. While foam, for example, can cost as low as $1.65 to $2.50 per square foot. Metal roofs are an expensive investment for homeowners.

If you assume your roof is 2,500 square feet, you can see a simple cost comparison.

  • Metal roofing materials, at $8 per square foot, would cost roughly $20,000.*
  • Foam roofing materials, at $2 per square foot, would cost roughly $5,000.*
  • Clay roofing materials, at $3.50 per square foot, would cost roughly $8,750.*

*This price does not include labor or installation. 

metal-roofing-home-steel-expensive

Consider Weather and Noise

Aluminum roofs help keep rain and snow from collecting, weather can still cause problems. Without attic space or proper substrate, noisy outdoor elements (like wind, rain, and branches) can be heard within a home. Heavy objects, like big branches or hail, can also dent a metal roof. A storm-dented roof carries the risk of moisture buildup, which can cause rust and leaking. Because of the price of supplies, replacing a metal panel is costlier than other roofing materials.

If you are sensitive to noise, consider a less expensive, quieter roof material. Rubber shingles are resistant to rotting, cracking, mold, and discoloration. Rubber is also resistant to denting and moisture-absorption, but at a much lower cost (as low as $3 per square foot).  

metal-roof-replacement-on-home

Select a Roof With a Long Lifespan

A metal roof will serve your home for many years, but there are other roofing alternatives that are also dependable for decades. Concrete or cement tiles will last 50 years or more. Clay tiles have a life expectancy of 100 years and are very cost effective.

Slate is very expensive and is often referred to as a “lifetime” roof. Slate has a life expectancy of more than 150 years and helps with the resale value of a home.

Ready to take the next step toward your roof replacement project? We can help. Receive up to four quotes from local, reliable roofing contractors to begin your home improvement project.

Find the Right Contractor for Your Roof Project

Whether you’re ready to begin your project now or need some expert advice, our network of contractors are here to help. With a few simple questions, we’ll find the best local professionals for you

Recommended Articles

Mother and daughter painting a wall together

Other Home Projects

Affordable Home Upgrades

We’ve all had that moment walking into a room thinking, “It’s fine, but…” Sometimes it’s dated hardware. Sometimes it’s lighting. Sometimes it’s just that nothing feels fresh anymore. Here’s the good news. You do not need a full renovation to fix it, and you do not need to tackle everything at once. The smarter approach…

Technician with clipboard looking at air conditioner for manual j calculation

HVAC

A Complete Manual J Guide

Manual J Load Calculations: The Essential Guide to Sizing a Home HVAC System Correctly When a homeowner needs a new HVAC system, one of the most important — yet least understood — steps in the process is the Manual J load calculation. While many contractors still rely on outdated rules of thumb, the reality is…

roof repair in progress

Roofing

Common Roofing Scams & How to Avoid Them

What to Know About Roofing Scams Your roof is one of the most important parts of your home — and one of the costliest to repair or replace. Unfortunately, that makes roofing a prime target for scammers looking to take advantage of homeowners after storms, during insurance claims, or when offering suspiciously cheap services. Knowing…

Dual-fuel portable generator connected to a propane tank

Generators

15 Practical Ways Homeowners Can Use a Generator

More Than Just Backup Power When people think about generators, they often picture them humming away during a blackout. While that is their most common role, generators are surprisingly versatile. From protecting your home during emergencies to powering up backyard celebrations, they can provide reliable electricity in many situations that would otherwise cause major inconvenience.…

Reviews from Real Homeowners

About Us

Welcome to Homeowner Resources! We are the Modernize blog. Modernize pairs more than 3 million homeowners a year with pre-vetted contractors in their area. This blog started because we believe homeowners should know everything about their homes, from how their HVAC works to which front door colors they might love. On Homeowner Resources, you can find information on every part of your home, right down to how you can negotiate with contractors to get the best price. Here's more about the blog.

Need a contractor? Learn more about how Modernize finds the right pro for you.