Are you doing an HVAC project?
Modernize can pair you with three to four pros in your area, so you can compare options and save time and money.
Choosing between a heat pump and a furnace is key to maintaining comfort and energy efficiency in your home year-round. While furnaces have traditionally been the go-to for heating in colder climates, heat pumps are gaining popularity due to their ability to both heat and cool, often at a lower cost and with greater energy efficiency. This guide compares heat pumps vs. furnaces in terms of cost, efficiency, maintenance, and longevity to help you determine the best option for your home’s needs and budget.
What Is a Heat Pump?
A heat pump is a device that transfers heat from one place to another, providing both heating in the winter and cooling in the summer. In the winter, a heat pump pulls warm air from outside and distributes it throughout the home. This process is reversed in the summer — the heat pump pulls hot air from inside your home and vents it outside.
There are three different types of heat pumps. Each one is best for specific types of homes, depending on when your house was built and the climate in which you reside.
- Ductless Heat Pumps: These models are best for older homes and for homes that don’t have existing ductwork.
- Ducted Heat Pumps: These systems connect to your home’s existing ductwork to distribute heated or cooled air efficiently, making them ideal for newer homes or those already equipped with ducts.
- Geothermal Heat Pumps: These pump types use heat from the ground or hot water sources near your home. These heat pumps can be a good option for homes in climates that are prone to extremely cold weather.
What Is a Furnace?
A furnace is a heating system that generates heat by burning fuel or using electricity and distributes it throughout the home. A furnace works by heating air through combustion (using gas or propane) or electric resistance, then using a blower fan to push the warm air through ductwork and into the rooms of your home.
A gas or propane furnace works by burning the fuel source to create heat, which is passed through a heat exchanger and then is forced throughout the home by the unit’s blower fan. Electric furnaces work the same way but use electricity to generate heat.
Find the Right Contractor for Your HVAC Project
Whether you’re ready to begin your project now or need some expert advice, our network of contractors are here to help. With a few simple questions, we’ll find the best local professionals for you
Side-by-Side Comparisons: Heat Pumps vs. Furnaces
Below we’ve laid out head-to-head comparisons of heat pumps vs furnaces in cost, efficiency, maintenance and longevity.
| Heat Pumps | Furnaces | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | $2,500 to $10,000 | $2,800 to $6,800 |
| Maintenance | Efficiency can drop 10-25% without proper maintenance; change filters, clean coils and fans, and check refrigerant and airflow. Annual inspection by an HVAC technician recommended. | Annual maintenance required to ensure efficiency; inspect the thermostat, ignition, blower, and other parts to prolong the unit's life. |
| Energy Efficiency | Can achieve efficiencies of 200-300% by moving heat rather than generating it; COP (Coefficient of Performance) varies by temperature. | Efficiency ranges from 80% to 98% AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency) for gas furnaces; electric furnaces are 100% efficient but have higher operating costs. |
| Longevity | 15+ Years | 20+ Years |
Packaged systems: Heat Pump-Furnace combos
Some homeowners — especially those in cold climates where heat pumps can struggle to deliver optimal efficiency — chose dual systems to provide robust heating throughout the home.
Dual systems pair heat pumps with furnaces for unmatched performance. The systems alternate depending on the weather. In moderately cool temperatures, the heat pump handles all the heat duties. In frigid weather, the furnace takes over to provide a more consistent heat source with less energy consumption.
Although dual systems can reduce your energy bills by maximizing each appliance’s efficiency, homeowners should weigh the costs of having two appliances versus buying a new high-efficiency furnace or a heat pump specifically designed to operate in cold temperatures.
Heat Pump vs. Furnace: Which Is Right for Me?
Choosing between a heat pump and a furnace depends on your climate, energy costs, and specific heating needs. Heat pumps are highly efficient and versatile, providing both heating and cooling at lower operating costs, especially in milder climates. However, in colder regions, a furnace may offer more reliable performance and consistent heating during extreme winter temperatures. If you prioritize year-round efficiency and live in a moderate climate, a heat pump could be the ideal choice. For those in areas with harsh winters, a high-efficiency furnace might be a better option. Consider your home’s location, budget, and energy preferences to decide which system best suits your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions About Heat Pumps vs. Furnaces
Find the Right Contractor for Your HVAC Project
Whether you’re ready to begin your project now or need some expert advice, our network of contractors are here to help. With a few simple questions, we’ll find the best local professionals for you
-
research and planningHeat Pump vs. AC: Which Is Best for You?
When it’s time to install or replace a new HVAC system, you may face the difficult decision of choosing between a heat pump vs. a central air conditioning (AC) unit.... -
cost and budgeting
Calculating the Return on Your Air Conditioning Investment
Compared to other home renovation projects, calculating your estimated air conditioning return on investment can be tricky — but don’t let that intimidate you away from it! One of the... -
research and planning
Understanding HVAC SEER Ratings: What Homeowners Need to Know
Understanding SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) ratings is crucial when choosing the right HVAC system for your home. These ratings not only determine the energy efficiency of your heating and... -
research and planning
Save Money on Your Utility Bill With a Heat Pump
Nobody likes paying utility bills — I sure don’t. But some people pay more than they have to by relying on inefficient heating and cooling methods. A standard gas furnace...
Reviews from Real Homeowners
Welcome to Homeowner Resources! We are the Modernize blog. Modernize pairs more than 3 million homeowners a year with pre-vetted contractors in their area. This blog started because we believe homeowners should know everything about their homes, from how their HVAC works to which front door colors they might love. On Homeowner Resources, you can find information on every part of your home, right down to how you can negotiate with contractors to get the best price. Here's more about the blog.
Need a contractor? Learn more about how Modernize finds the right pro for you.