Enter your zip to
find local pros.
Please enter a valid 5 digit zip code

Gutters

All American Gutter Protection Review 2024

Modernize Rating: 4/5

Average Cost: $4,000 - $6,000

All American Gutter Protection offers a solution that fits all existing roofs and gutters to prevent clogs and debris build-up in your home’s water drainage system. Their micro mesh guard costs between $15 to $30 per linear foot depending on the specifics of your roof and current gutter system. The company receives good reviews for the durability of its products and its guarantees, but it is a bit more expensive than many competitors.

The Modernize Mission

Modernize maintains homeowner-first editorial integrity, meaning we accept no commissions and no partner links for this review. Our reviews are thoroughly fact-checked by our home improvement experts. Ratings are determined by a sophisticated algorithm to rate brands, including analyses of products, materials, quality, costs, sizes, durability, energy efficiency, and warranties.

All American Gutter Protection Review Overview

All American Gutter Protection has been in the gutter business for more than 50 years, offering homeowners a long-term solution to their gutter cleaning problems. With locations in at least 15 states and counting, the company continues to expand and has become well regarded for its reliable product and long-lasting warranty. The company uses a micro-mesh gutter guard to prevent debris from entering and clogging your home’s gutters, increasing the life of your gutters and protecting your home from water damage. The company also offers gutter installation, servicing of downspouts, replacement of fascia boards and gutter cleaning.

All American Gutter Protection

All American Gutter Protection Review: Pros and Cons

There are a few pros and cons when choosing all American Gutter Protection.

  • Pros

    • Durable Materials
    • Effective Debris Protection
    • Custom Fit
  • Cons

    • Higher Initial Cost
    • Requires Professional Installation
    • Limited Availability

Pros

  • Durable Materials: All American Gutter Protection makes its gutter guards with a 100% aluminum body and a stainless steel micro mesh screen that resists bending, warping and cracking. The company also offers seamless gutter installation. Its products are weather resistant with a low profile.
  • Effective Debris Protection: All American Gutter Protection’s systems prevent large and small debris from entering your gutters and downspouts, allowing for free waterflow without the need of any maintenance. To back this, the company promises a lifetime warranty on its products and their performance.
  • Custom Fit: All American Gutter Protection’s guard system is designed for installation on any existing roof or gutter system and works to prevent debris without damaging your existing roof or gutters. If your home needs new gutters before installation, the company can also assist.

Cons

  • Higher Initial Cost: The upfront cost for guards from All American Gutter Protection can be higher compared to some competitors, making it less appealing to some potential customers.
  • Requires Professional Installation: Unlike some other options, All American Gutter Protection requires professional installation, which costs additional money.
  • Limited Availability: While the company continues to grow, All American Gutter Protection is not currently available in all states. Their website also has conflicting information about its locations, listing 15, 18 and 20 states on different pages.

All American Gutter Protection Gutter Guard Features

All American Gutter Protection provides one type of gutter guard with tons of impressive features.

  • Aluminum and Stainless Steel: The company’s gutter guards are made with aluminum bodies and stainless steel micro mesh designed to resist warping, fading and cracking.
  • Micro Mesh: The company’s micro mesh is designed to allow for free flow of water while preventing debris both large and small from entering.
  • Weather Resistant: Gutters are exposed to the sun, temperature and precipitation year round. All American Gutter Protection offers weather resistant materials designed to withstand the elements while preventing damage to your roof caused by heavy snowfall and freezing temperatures.
  • One Size Fits All: Rather than have your entire gutter system replaced and then outfitted with guards, All American Gutter Protection can install its micro mesh guards on any style of existing gutter or roofing. This of course requires that your current roof and gutter system are in good condition. If you need new gutters first, the company can also install them for you.
  • Low Profile: These micro-mesh guards are installed over your gutters at the same pitch of your roof to ensure water flows over and does not pool on top of the guards. The result is an aesthetically pleasing, low profile design.
  • Comes in 30 Colors: ​​The company also offers its guards and gutters in 30 different colors to match or coordinate with your current roof and house color.

How Much Does All American Gutter Protection Cost?

The cost for All American Gutter Protection’s systems typically ranges from $15 to $30 per linear foot, depending on a few different factors for your roof. Professional installation fees are often charged in addition to this amount and will vary based on where you live and how big your home is.

Keep in mind that All American Gutter Protection offers financing for customers who qualify. They also offer regular promotions, including discounts for seniors and members of the military.

In general, the company does not offer much pricing information on its site and instead directs potential customers to call or get in touch for an estimate. It’s not clear whether these estimates are free.

Gutter Replacement Cost Calculator

Take Me There

Factors Affecting Cost

  • Home Size: Perhaps the biggest factor affecting the cost of your All American Gutter Protection installation is the overall size and complexity of your home. Larger homes will require more materials and time. In addition, homes with unique roofs, a high number of corners and valleys, and any additional stories will be more complicated and will therefore cost more.
  • Roof and Gutter Condition: Installation will be most affordable for homes whose gutters and roofs are in great shape. Homes with older roofs and gutters might need additional work in order for these guards to work. In some cases, entire gutter systems will need to be replaced in order to accommodate these guards, driving up the price.
  • Geographic Location: Labor and materials will vary in cost based on where in the country you live.

Benefits of Investing in All American Gutter Protection

Investing in All American Gutter Protection provides several advantages. Customers love that they no longer have to clean or maintain their gutters. In addition, gutter guards are shown to increase the lifespan of your current gutters by protecting them from heavy debris that could make them sag or fall off and damage your roof.

Not only that, but proper gutter drainage is also shown to prevent water damage to your home’s foundation and landscaping, which makes for a great long-term investment.

When you specifically invest in All American Gutter Protection, you also get their lifetime warranty, which means you’re investing in a product guaranteed to last long term.

Image from All American Gutter Protection website showing a contractor installing their gutters

All American Gutter Protection vs. Its Competitors

As you shop, be sure to compare All American Gutter Protection to other companies.

  • Gutter Helmet: Gutter Helmet uses a surface tension guard system to keep debris from entering your gutters. Their aluminum reverse-curve design and a ribbed surface creates surface tension that caches and removes debris so only water can enter your gutters. The company also offers a lifetime warranty on its products and has been rated as being a bit on the expensive side by customers. In addition, some customers have reported that debris sometimes does enter their gutters. The company has a larger presence than All American Gutter Protection, with locations in 40 states.
  • Leafguard: Leafguard approaches gutter protection with a full replacement of your gutters. Their patented, one-piece gutter system is designed without seams and prevents debris large and small from entering. In business for 25 years, the company offers a lifetime, transferable warranty on its stainless steel mesh design and the gutters are designed to resist chipping and cracking. They currently operate in 36 states.
  • LeafFilter: LeafFilter’s design combines surface tension technology with a sealed system and built-in pitch to prevent debris from entering. It also uses micro mesh and is designed to work with your existing gutters, assuming they’re in good shape. The company offers a lifetime, transferable warranty and a 100% no clog guarantee. They operate in 39 states and have been in business since 2005.

Is All American Gutter Protection Right for Me?

All American Gutter Protection is ideal for homeowners looking for a high-quality, long-term solution to their gutter health and protection. It might be right for you if you’re located in one of the states they service and willing to invest in a somewhat pricier gutter solution for your home. Keep in mind that All American Gutter Protection is ideal for homeowners with existing gutters that are in good shape. In addition, the company has several color options, offers financing and professional installation for its product.

Compare top-rated gutters pros in your area.

Read real homeowner reviews, explore qualifications, and view promotions. Modernize makes it easy to browse professionals and find one that will be perfect for your project.