Choosing the right heating and cooling system for your home or property can be a dilemma, with so many available choices and price ranges. This comparison guide lists the pros and cons of each system type, along with a current estimated cost for each style. Please note that costs for each system type vary by manufacturer, and the size of the unit needed depends on several factors along with square footage such as area layout, proper insulation, and no leakage around doors and windows.
Jump to content:
- HVAC Air Conditioning and Heating System
- Pros of HVAC Units:
- Cons of HVAC Units:
- Window Unit Air Conditioning System
- Pros of Window Units:
- Cons of Window Units:
- Portable Air Conditioning System
- Pros of Portable AC Units:
- Cons of Portable AC Units:
- Ductless or Mini-Split Air Conditioning and Heating System
- Pros of Ductless AC Units:
- Cons of Ductless AC Units:
HVAC Air Conditioning and Heating System
A standard HVAC heating and cooling system is cost effective and convenient, but it also has some drawbacks to alternative systems.
Pros of HVAC Units:
- HVAC systems provide overall cooling and heating to every room that is equipped with a vent connected to a network of ductwork.
- Systems will cycle on and off as the interior temperature needs to be adjusted.
- The standard for sizing is 1 ton per for every 500 square feet. For a 2,400 square foot property, you would need a minimum of a 5-ton unit.
- For an HVAC system for a 2,400 square foot area in Los Angeles, California, the low cost is approximately $3,904.56 and the high end is $4,825.80. This is for a 3-ton unit with a Seasonal Energy Efficient Rating of 18.
Cons of HVAC Units:
- Ductwork can be expensive and prone to leaking when damaged or due to deterioration from age.
- If you’re having a new system installed to replace or upgrade a current system, the ductwork may need to be updated or modified as well, to ensure it is compliant with the new system.
- For a new installation, you must factor in the cost of the ductwork and labor.
- Unlike a ductless system, you cannot individually adjust the temperature for each room.
Window Unit Air Conditioning System
Whether they’re installed in a window or a wall, this unit has been heating and cooling homes and businesses for many years, and with today’s technology, they have improved in energy efficiency.
Pros of Window Units:
- Window units come in a variety of sizes from 5,000 BTUs to 36,000 BTUs and are available for cooling only or for heating and cooling.
- These units are affordable, with current prices ranging from less than $400 to approximately $1,500.
- Window units are relatively easy to install—simply place in an appropriate window and provide support.
Cons of Window Units:
- Since the unit is installed in either a window or in the wall, it is not as versatile as a portable unit.
- Because the unit does not have a duct system with vents to every room, the immediate and surrounding area will feel the effects of the cooling sooner, while outlying areas will take more time to condition.
- A 12,000 BTU window unit is estimated to cover between 450 and 550 square feet. For a 2,400 square foot area, at least two 18,000 BTU units (18,000 BTUs covers up to 1,000 feet) are needed or one 28,000 BTU unit, which covers 2,200 square feet plus an additional 10,000 BTU unit to cover the remaining 450 square feet.
Portable Air Conditioning System
Portable air conditioners are an option known for their versatility. Here are a few things to consider when doing comparison shopping.
Pros of Portable AC Units:
- The beauty of portable units is the ability to move them whenever and wherever you like. By removing the drainage tube and window kit used to vent the hot air, the system is easily moved because it’s equipped with casters.
- Units are affordable, with prices ranging from less than $500 to $1,200.
- Portables are available in 8,000, 10,000, 12,000, 14,000 and 16,000 BTUs.
- Systems are available for cooling only, or for heating and cooling.
Cons of Portable AC Units:
- Homes or offices with carpet may find it difficult to roll the unit.
- A 12,000 BTU covers an area of 400 square feet. Six units are necessary to accommodate a 2,400 square foot area.
- Portables tend to have a lower Energy Efficiency Rating (EER).
Ductless or Mini-Split Air Conditioning and Heating System
Mini-split ductless systems are a newer option in heating and cooling. The unit is comprised of an external compressor/heat pump and internal inverter boxes that connect to the compressor. The boxes can be wall, floor, or ceiling mounted. Lines are run from the inverter box to the compressor; one copper for refrigerant, electric wiring and tubing for drainage and condensation.
Pros of Ductless AC Units:
- Mini-splits are ductless systems, which save money on the installation of a network of ductwork throughout the ceiling.
- A slim duct line ductless system is also an option, which uses minimal ductwork.
- Each inverter box is individually regulated with a remote, meaning you can turn off units in rooms not needing heating or cooling. Systems can be ordered with 1 to 8 inverter boxes depending on your needs.
- Systems use 208-230 voltage.
- Ductless systems come with a high Seasonal Energy Efficiency Rating (SEER) and Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF) that measures the efficiency of the heat pump.
Cons of Ductless AC Units:
- Systems are available with 12,000, 18,000, 24,000, 30,000, 36,000, 42,000 and 48,000 BTUs.
- A Multi-Zone (5 boxes) with 36,000 BTUs is estimated to cover 2,000 square feet. For homes or businesses with more square footage of 2,400 square feet, the addition of a single 12,000 BTU system with an inverter box may be necessary.
- Ductless systems are available from many manufacturers. Depending on the size needed, units can range in price for $650 to $6,500 at current prices.
- Units must be professionally installed due to wiring and refrigerant requirements.
What’s your preferred type of AC unit? Do you have an experience with one type over another? Tell us about it in the comments below!