Gutters
Average Cost: $4,000 - $6,000
Our Verdict: We recommend All American Gutter Protection if you want a warranty that actually covers the entire system, including the mesh. Most competitors charge you a service fee to unclog the mesh, but with All American, that’s covered for the lifetime of the product. Just know that installation quality depends on the crew you get, and some customers report same-day sales pressure. Get a few quotes and walk through the finished job before you sign off.
All American Gutter Protection has over 50 years of experience and installs micro-mesh gutter guards made in the USA. The company works in 18 states. Its main product installs over your existing gutters and comes with a Lifetime Performance Guarantee that covers the whole system, including the mesh. Most competitors don’t cover mesh clogs, so this is a meaningful advantage.
In addition to gutter guards, the company offers gutter installation, cleaning, downspout services, and fascia board replacement.
| Best for | Top Model | Cost Installed | Standout Feature | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homeowners seeking a long-term, low-maintenance gutter solution | Micro-mesh gutter guard | $4,000 to $6,000 | Durable aluminum frame with stainless steel mesh | Lifetime transferable product and labor warranty |
See what gutter guard installation costs in your area.
We recommend All American Gutter Protection mainly because of its warranty. (Curious how we evaluate products? See our gutter rating methodology.) Unlike most competitors, the warranty covers the whole system, including the mesh. With other brands, if the mesh clogs (which happens most often), you pay for the fix. All American’s Lifetime Performance Guarantee covers that, and the company spells it out clearly. If you’ve dealt with mesh clogs before, this coverage is a big deal.
You also get 30 color options, which is more than most brands offer. The guards install right over your current gutters, so you don’t need a full replacement.
There are some real drawbacks. Installation quality depends on the crew, the sales process often comes with same-day pricing pressure, and the service area is limited. If you’re in their coverage area and plan to stay in your home, it’s worth getting a quote.
All American Gutter Protection offers one core product with the following specifications:
All American Gutter Protection’s Lifetime Performance Guarantee covers the whole gutter guard system, including the mesh, for as long as you own your home. If the guards don’t work as promised, the company will fix it.
The warranty’s most significant feature is what it explicitly covers that competitors don’t. Many gutter guard warranties cover debris clogging inside the gutter trough but exclude the mesh surface itself. If debris mats on the mesh and causes overflow, that’s typically a service call at the homeowner’s expense under those warranties. All American directly addresses this gap, stating: “Many companies promise ‘no clogs’ but exclude the mesh itself from their warranty. That means if the screen clogs, you’re stuck with the problem. At All American, our warranty covers the entire system.”
The company doesn’t post the full legal warranty online. Before installation, ask for the complete written warranty and check for these details:
All American Gutter Protection has a 4.5-star rating from Modernize customers. Most reviews praise the crews for being professional, on time, and delivering solid results. The negative reviews point to two things you should know before you buy: installation quality can vary by crew, and some customers felt pressured to sign on the spot.
“Right before the fall leaves began to fall, I called All American, and they responded same day with an estimate, and had their crew on-site a few days later. Excellent quality gutters and downspouts, and the job was complete before the first fall leaves hit.” — Scott H., Google Reviewer
“Rex and Will called ahead to let us know exactly when they’d arrive, and they showed up right on time. They were friendly, professional, and efficient from start to finish. The quality of their work was excellent, and the whole experience was smooth and stress-free.” — Rick W., Modernize Reviewer
“Your salesman Spencer was a breath of fresh air — honest in his assessment of our gutter situation and did not try to oversell what we needed. We totally expected to be hit with a $10,000 quote to replace all our gutters. Your installer completed the job in about two hours while doing the job correctly.” — Angie and Eric Simmons, Google Reviewer
“Everything is staying out of my gutters except for the rain!” — Nancy, Modernize Reviewer
Most installation reviews are positive, but M.C.’s experience shows what can go wrong and what you should check before you sign off on the job.
“The installer showed up five days late with no contact from the company. He then refused to reschedule and insisted the job had to be done that day while I was at work. He did such a poor job re-pitching one of my gutters that it looks like he almost ripped it off. A large part of the mesh is not angled correctly — instead it is flat, causing leaves to build up on top. My gutter is now dented in places it wasn’t before.” — M.C., Google Reviewer
The specific failure M.C. describes (flat mesh instead of the promised angled pitch) directly undermines one of the product’s core design features. Before the crew leaves, confirm the mesh is installed at your roof’s pitch, not flat. Do a full walkthrough and don’t sign the completion form until you’re satisfied.
Angie and Eric Simmons praised their salesperson for being honest and not overselling. But not everyone has the same experience. Megan Klingler’s was the opposite.
“The estimator was very pushy and repeatedly lowered the quoted price in an effort to get us to sign immediately. At one point, we were told ‘if the price was good, you would have signed by now.’ I felt increasingly uneasy in my own home. Once we clearly stated we would not be signing that day, the estimator’s demeanor changed noticeably and he left rather abruptly. No one should feel pressured when getting quotes for a significant investment like this.” — Megan Klingler, Google Reviewer
This same-day pressure isn’t unique to All American. You never have to decide on the spot. Bring a competing quote to your appointment — it’s your best protection.
All American Gutter Protection typically costs $15–$30 per linear foot installed. For a home with around 200 linear feet of gutters, most projects run $4,000–$6,000. The company cites an average project cost of approximately $5,868.
You won’t find pricing online — all quotes are done in person. Sales reps often drop the price during the visit, so there’s room to negotiate. Bring a competing quote to your consultation for the best leverage. See our full guide to gutter guard costs to know what’s reasonable before you sit down with a rep.
All American Gutter Protection offers financing for qualifying customers. Regular promotions include discounts for seniors and military members. Ask about current offers during your consultation and confirm financing APR and terms before signing.
Here’s how All American Gutter Protection compares to the top three alternatives in its price and service range. For a broader look at the market, see our guide to the best gutter guard brands.
Gutter Helmet uses a reverse-curve aluminum design that channels water into your gutters and lets debris fall off the edge. It installs over your existing gutters and is available in 40 states, so it’s easier to find than All American. Costs usually run $2,000–$5,000, which is often less than All American. Gutter Helmet does a good job with large debris and works in cold weather, but it can let in pine needles and shingle grit. If you’re worried about fine debris, All American’s micro-mesh does a better job keeping it out.
Leafguard swaps out your whole gutter system for a seamless, one-piece unit instead of installing over what you already have. It costs $3,000–$9,000 and is available in 36 states. Leafguard’s no-clog guarantee covers free cleaning for any type of clog, and there are plenty of long-term reviews from 15–30 years out. The catch is you have to replace your gutters. All American keeps your existing gutters and usually costs less if your gutters are in good shape. If your gutters are old and need replacing anyway, Leafguard is worth a look.
LeafFilter installs a 275-micron stainless steel micro-mesh over your existing gutters and works in 47 states, so it’s easier to find than All American. It costs $3,000–$8,000 and comes with a transferable lifetime warranty. The big difference is the warranty: LeafFilter only covers clogs inside the gutter. If the mesh itself clogs, you’ll pay $95 for service. All American’s warranty covers the mesh too. If you’re in All American’s service area and want full coverage, that’s a key advantage. If you’re outside their area, LeafFilter’s wide availability makes it the next best option.
All American Gutter Protection is a solid pick if you’re in their service area and want a full-system warranty that covers the mesh, not just the inside of the gutter. You also get 30 color options, pro installation, and real discounts for seniors and military members.
But there are some drawbacks: the service area is limited, installation quality depends on the crew, and some sales reps push for same-day decisions. M.C.’s experience with flat mesh, dented gutters, and no communication is a good reminder to do a walkthrough before you sign off on the job.
Ready to compare gutter guard quotes in your area?
