Champion Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen: How to Choose

Champion Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen Overview

Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen are both well-known window replacement companies, but they serve different types of homeowners. Champion is typically more budget-friendly and vinyl-focused, while Renewal by Andersen emphasizes premium materials, full-service installation, and long-term performance.

Feature	Champion Windows	Renewal by Andersen
Primary Materials	Vinyl, limited wood options	Fibrex composite
Average Installed Cost	$500 to $1,200 per window	$900 to $1,700 per window
Customization	Moderate	Extensive
Installation Model	In-house installers	Full-service, in-house crews
Warranty	Limited lifetime	20-year transferable warranty

Champion Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen Cost Difference

The biggest difference between Champion and Renewal by Andersen is cost. Champion tends to appeal to homeowners focused on affordability, while Renewal by Andersen sits firmly in the premium window category.

Champion Windows: $500 to $1,200 per window installed
Renewal by Andersen: $900 to $1,700 per window installed

Below is a side-by-side comparison of similar window styles.

Window Style	Champion Installed Cost	Renewal by Andersen Installed Cost
Double-Hung	$550 to $1,000	$950 to $1,600
Casement	$650 to $1,200	$1,100 to $1,700
Picture Window	$500 to $900	$900 to $1,400

Champion Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen Reviews

Customer reviews often highlight pricing transparency, installation experience, and long-term performance.

Champion Windows

Homeowners frequently mention competitive pricing and efficient installation. Some reviews note limited customization compared to higher-end brands.

Overall, Champion gets 3.6 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot and 4.4 stars on the company’s own website.

Read our Champion Windows review here.

Renewal by Andersen

Renewal by Andersen receives strong marks for installation quality, product durability, and customer service, with cost being the most common concern.

Overall, Renewal by Andersen gets 3.11 stars on bbb.org and 4.7 stars on the company’s own website.

Read our Renewal by Andersen review here.

Champion vs. Andersen: How to Choose

Budget

If keeping upfront costs low is your top priority, Champion Windows is typically the more affordable choice. Renewal by Andersen requires a higher initial investment but may deliver more value over time.

Materials

Champion focuses primarily on vinyl windows, which are cost-effective and low maintenance. Renewal by Andersen uses Fibrex composite frames, designed for added strength, stability, and insulation.

Window Types

Both brands offer popular styles such as double-hung, casement, and picture windows. Renewal by Andersen provides more flexibility for large openings and custom sizes.

Service and Warranty

Champion offers a limited lifetime warranty, while Renewal by Andersen includes a more comprehensive, transferable warranty that covers materials and installation for longer periods.

Durability and Lifespan

Vinyl windows from Champion typically last 20 to 30 years with proper maintenance.
Renewal by Andersen’s Fibrex windows are designed to last longer, especially in extreme climates.

More Window Brand Comparisons

See our best window brands guide to review top window manufacturers, and check out our other comparison pages:

Which Is Better, Champion or Andersen?

Which brand is better will depend on your goals, budget, and window needs. Champion Windows is often a good fit for budget-conscious replacements, while Renewal by Andersen works well for homeowners prioritizing long-term durability and premium service.

Modernize can help you compare Champion Windows, Renewal by Andersen, and other top window brands by connecting you with trusted local window contractors for side-by-side quotes.

Compare top-rated windows pros in your area.

Read real homeowner reviews, explore qualifications, and view promotions. Modernize makes it easy to browse professionals and find one that will be perfect for your project.