Windows
Marvin vs. Andersen Windows Comparison
On this page
- Marvin vs. Andersen Windows Comparison Table
- What to Know About Both Brands
- Series Comparison
Find the best windows pros in your area.
The Modernize Mission
We help homeowners make confident decisions through our reliable, up-to-date, and unbiased information and average project costs. All of our content is thoroughly reviewed and fact-checked by our team of home improvement experts. Learn more about how we maintain these values.
Marvin vs. Andersen Windows: Which Is Right for You?
Choosing between Marvin and Andersen windows often comes down to budget, customization needs, and long-term performance. Both brands are well-known for quality, but they serve slightly different homeowners, especially when value, durability, and energy savings matter more than ever. Marvin and Andersen are premium window manufacturers with decades of experience, strong warranties, and multiple product lines. The right choice depends on whether you prioritize custom design and materials or upfront affordability and installation convenience.
| Feature | Marvin | Andersen |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1912 – over 110 years in business | 1903 – over 120 years in business |
| Materials | Wood, fiberglass (Ultrex), aluminum-clad wood | Wood, Fibrex® composite, limited vinyl (Renewal by Andersen) |
| Flagship Series | Signature Collection (custom wood and aluminum-clad designs) | 400 Series (wood/clad with Perma-Shield exteriors) |
| Other Series | Essential, Elevate, Modern, Coastline | 100, 200, A-Series, E-Series, Aluminum (regional), Renewal by Andersen |
| Customization | Exceptional design flexibility, custom sizes, finishes, and hardware | Extensive options, especially in higher-end architectural lines |
| Energy Efficiency | ENERGY STAR® certified options; strong thermal performance with Ultrex frames | ENERGY STAR® certified lines; Fibrex frames offer strong insulation |
| Price Range | $400 to $3,000+ per window | $200 to $2,500+ per window |
| Warranty | 20 years glass, 10 years frame and hardware | 20 years glass, 20 years frame, 10 years hardware, 5 years labor (Renewal by Andersen) |
| Best For | High-end customization, modern designs, and premium materials | Broader budget range and full-service installation options |
Marvin vs. Andersen: What You Need to Know
Before choosing from top window brands, it helps to understand how Marvin and Andersen differ in cost structure, performance, and long-term value.
Learn the difference between Andersen Windows and Renewal by Andersen.
Cost by Brand: How Much Are Marvin Windows Compared to Andersen Windows?
Marvin windows generally cost more upfront due to their custom manufacturing approach and premium materials. Andersen offers a wider range of price points, including more budget-friendly options like the 100 and 200 Series. In a slower economy, Andersen may appeal to homeowners looking to balance quality with affordability.
Cost by Brand: Marvin vs. Andersen Windows
Marvin windows generally cost more than Andersen Windows and less than Renewal by Andersen upfront due to their custom manufacturing approach and premium materials. Andersen Windows offers a wider range of price points, including more budget-friendly options like the 100 and 200 Series. In a slower economy, Andersen Windows may appeal to homeowners looking to balance quality with affordability.
| Brand | Average Installed Cost Per Window | Best Known For |
|---|---|---|
| Andersen (Retail Lines – 100, 200, 400 Series) | $500 to $2,000 | Wide price range, wood and composite options |
| Renewal by Andersen | $1,000 to $3,500 | Full-service replacement and Fibrex® composite frames |
| Marvin (Essential, Elevate, Signature) | $700 to $2,500 | Premium fiberglass and wood-clad customization |
Bottom Line: Marvin typically costs more than Andersen’s entry-level retail lines but competes closely with Andersen’s 400 Series and premium collections. Renewal by Andersen generally carries the highest installed pricing due to its bundled installation model.
Other reviews to check out:
Brand History
Both companies have deep roots in the window industry. Andersen is the larger manufacturer with broader distribution, while Marvin remains family-owned and focused on craftsmanship and architectural detail.
Efficiency
Both brands offer ENERGY STAR certified products with Low-E glass and insulated frames. Marvin’s Ultrex fiberglass frames excel in temperature stability, while Andersen’s Fibrex composite frames are designed to resist moisture and expansion.
Best for Saving Money and Increasing Home Value
This will depend on what you’re looking for.
- Andersen is often the better option for homeowners focused on resale value and predictable returns, especially with its widely recognized brand name.
- Marvin may deliver higher value in custom homes or high-end remodels where design and materials matter more than upfront window installation cost.
Customer Ratings and Reviews
Both brands receive strong reviews for durability and performance. Andersen is frequently praised for availability and installation options, while Marvin earns high marks for build quality and aesthetics.
Is Marvin windows better than Andersen? Neither brand is universally better. Marvin stands out for customization and premium design, while Andersen offers broader accessibility and more price flexibility.
Marvin vs. Andersen Windows: Series Comparison
Comparing similar product lines can help you see how costs and features stack up.
Marvin Essential vs. Andersen 400 and Andersen 100
Marvin Essential uses Ultrex fiberglass and sits above Andersen 100 in price but below Andersen 400. It offers excellent durability with fewer customization options, while Andersen 400 provides more wood-clad appeal.
Marvin Elevate vs. Andersen A-Series
Both lines target premium buyers. Marvin Elevate combines wood interiors with fiberglass exteriors, while Andersen A-Series focuses on architectural-grade wood windows with extensive customization.
Andersen Fibrex vs. Marvin Ultrex
Fibrex is a composite material designed for strength and insulation, while Ultrex fiberglass is known for rigidity and minimal expansion. Both perform well, but Ultrex tends to appeal to homeowners in extreme climates.
Marvin vs. Andersen vs. Pella
When compared to Pella, Marvin typically ranks highest for customization, Andersen offers the broadest pricing range and installation options, and Pella often appeals to homeowners seeking energy-efficient midrange solutions. The best choice depends on budget, design goals, and availability in your area.
More window brand comparisons:
- Champion Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen
- Renewal by Andersen vs. Andersen Windows
- Pella vs. Andersen
- Pella vs. Marvin
- Milgard vs. Andersen
Next Steps
If you’re deciding between Marvin and Andersen windows, start by identifying your priorities: budget, customization, energy efficiency, or installation convenience. Getting quotes from local contractors can help you compare real-world pricing and availability.
Modernize can connect you with pre-vetted window installers who work with Marvin, Andersen, and other top brands. You’ll get no-obligation expert guidance, competitive quotes, and the confidence to move forward with the right windows for your home.
Related Guides
Modernize Customer Portal Select your product below to sign in.
Modernize Bathroom Remodel Rating Methodology
How We Rate Bathroom Remodel Products and Companies We use two different sets of criteria depending on what we’re rating. For products and brands (like bathtubs, showerheads, and steam shower systems), we focus on how well they perform their core function, how durably they’re built, how much they cost relative to what you get, and how easy they are…
