Renewal by Andersen vs. Andersen Windows: What’s the Difference?
The biggest difference between Andersen Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen comes down to how you buy and install the windows. Andersen Windows sells products through retailers and local contractors, giving homeowners more control over pricing and installation. Renewal by Andersen is Andersen’s in-house replacement division, offering a turnkey experience that includes consultation, manufacturing, installation, and warranty coverage.
In short, Andersen Windows offers more flexibility, while Renewal by Andersen prioritizes convenience and consistency.
Which Is Right for You?
Choosing between Andersen Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen depends on your budget, how involved you want to be in the process, and whether you prefer a full-service solution or more customization options.
| Feature | Andersen Windows | Renewal by Andersen |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Budget flexibility and product variety | Full-service, hassle-free replacement |
| Avoid If | You want one company to handle everything | You need the lowest upfront cost |
| Window Types | Full new construction and replacement lines | Replacement windows only |
| Customization | Extensive across multiple product lines | Limited to Renewal-exclusive options |
Renewal by Andersen vs. Andersen Windows: Installation Process
- Andersen Windows are installed by independent, licensed window contractors or builders you choose. Installation quality can vary depending on the installer.
- Renewal by Andersen uses its own certified installation teams. This creates a more consistent experience and allows the company to offer stronger labor warranties.
Products
- Andersen Windows offers a wide range of products, including new construction, replacement, and specialty windows.
- Renewal by Andersen focuses exclusively on replacement windows.
Top Window Lines
- Andersen’s most popular lines include the 100 Series, 400 Series, A-Series, and E-Series.
- Renewal by Andersen uses a proprietary line designed specifically for replacement projects.
Top Material
Both options use Fibrex composite frames. Andersen Windows also offers wood, aluminum, and composite options depending on the series, while Renewal by Andersen exclusively uses Fibrex.
Energy Efficiency
Both Andersen Windows and Renewal by Andersen offer ENERGY STAR certified products. Fibrex frames provide strong insulation, and homeowners can choose Low-E glass packages to improve efficiency.
Financing
- Andersen Windows financing depends on the retailer or contractor you choose.
- Renewal by Andersen offers in-house financing options, which can make larger projects easier to manage.
Cost
Andersen Windows typically cost less because you can shop around for installation and choose from budget-friendly product lines like the 100 Series.
| Brand / Product Line | Average Window Cost (Unit Only) | Average Installed Cost Per Window | What’s Included |
|---|---|---|---|
| Andersen 100 Series | $300 to $700 | $500 to $1,200 | Composite window; installation priced separately |
| Andersen 200 Series | $400 to $900 | $600 to $1,500 | Wood interior with vinyl exterior; dealer-installed |
| Andersen 400 Series | $500 to $1,200 | $800 to $2,000 | Premium wood-clad line; installer pricing varies |
| Renewal by Andersen | Not sold separately | $1,000 to $3,500 | Custom manufacturing, installation, labor warranty, and service included |
Key Difference: Andersen retail windows allow you to separate product and installation costs, which can reduce total pricing. Renewal by Andersen bundles consultation, manufacturing, installation, and warranty coverage into one package, resulting in higher upfront costs.
Why is Renewal by Andersen more expensive? Renewal by Andersen window costs include consultation, custom manufacturing, professional installation, and extended warranties in one package. That convenience and service model results in higher upfront pricing.
Customer Service
- Customer service for Andersen Windows depends largely on the local contractor or retailer.
- Renewal by Andersen provides centralized customer support, which many homeowners find easier to navigate.
Warranties
- Andersen Windows typically include a 20-year glass warranty and 10-year coverage on other components, with labor warranties varying by installer.
- Renewal by Andersen offers one of the strongest warranty packages, including product and installation coverage handled by the same company.
Andersen vs. Competitors
When comparing Andersen Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen to other top window brands, differences in pricing, customization, and service become clearer.
Check out our other brand comparisons:
| Brand | Price Range | Best Known For |
|---|---|---|
| Andersen Windows | Mid-range to premium | Wide product selection and brand reputation |
| Renewal by Andersen | Premium | Full-service replacement and installation |
| Pella | Mid-range to premium | Energy-efficient and design-forward options |
| Marvin | Premium | High-end customization and materials |
| Simonton | Budget to mid-range | Affordable vinyl windows |
Renewal by Andersen vs. Andersen Windows: Next Steps
If you value convenience and want a single company to manage your entire project, Renewal by Andersen may be the better fit. If you prefer more control over pricing and product selection, Andersen Windows paired with a trusted local contractor may offer better value.
Modernize can help you compare both options by connecting you with pre-vetted window professionals who work with Andersen products. Get multiple quotes, expert guidance, and the confidence to choose the right solution for your home.
Compare top-rated windows pros in your area.
Read real homeowner reviews, explore qualifications, and view promotions. Modernize makes it easy to browse professionals and find one that will be perfect for your project.
-
Marvin vs. Andersen Windows Comparison
Marvin vs. Andersen Windows: Which Is Right for You? Choosing between Marvin and Andersen windows often comes down to budget, customization needs, and long-term performance. Both brands are well-known for... -
Champion Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen
Champion Windows vs. Renewal by Andersen Overview Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen are both well-known window replacement companies, but they serve different types of homeowners. Champion is typically more... -
Pella vs. Marvin Windows Comparison
Pella vs. Marvin Windows Overview Pella and Marvin are two of the most respected window brands in the industry, and both are known for strong performance, solid warranties, and premium... -
Andersen Windows vs. Milgard
Milgard vs Andersen Overview Andersen is one of the most established window brands in the U.S., offering wood, composite (Fibrex®), and fiberglass windows across multiple product lines. Renewal by Andersen... -
Anlin Windows vs. Milgard Windows
Milgard Windows vs. Anlin Windows Overview Milgard is a national brand (strongest in the Western U.S.) offering vinyl, fiberglass, and aluminum windows across multiple price points. Anlin is a California-based... -
How Much Does Window Nation Cost in 2026?
Average Cost for Window Nation Windows Window Nation doesn’t publish prices on their site, but third-party sources provide estimates of the company’s average window costs. Expect to pay between $300...