Window Sash Replacement Cost
Maybe that twig hit too hard, or the neighbor’s kid kicked the ball a bit too far. Whatever the cause, your window is in bad shape, and now you need...
Windows
Pella and Andersen are two of the top window brands in the U.S., each with a long history of craftsmanship, energy efficiency, and design innovation. While both offer excellent products, the right choice for your home depends on factors like budget, style preferences, warranty coverage, and installation options. This comparison breaks down the key differences in cost, materials, and performance so you can make the most informed decision.
Pella and Andersen are two powerhouses in the window industry, which can make it tough to choose between them when it’s time for new windows for your home. The good news is that you can’t go wrong with either option. However, our Pella vs. Andersen comparison review will give you strong insight into the different product lines, unique options, costs for each, and what to expect from installation and more. Read on to learn what you need to know to make the best decision for your home.
| Feature | Pella | Andersen |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1925 — over 95 years in business | 1903 — over 120 years in business |
| Materials | Wood, fiberglass, vinyl | Wood, Fibrex® composite, limited vinyl (Renewal by Andersen) |
| Flagship Series | Lifestyle Series (wood/clad, energy-efficient, smart add-ons) | 400 Series (wood/clad, durable, Perma-Shield exteriors) |
| Other Series | Reserve, Impervia, 250, Encompass, Specialty (Hurricane & Defender) | 100, 200, A-Series, E-Series, Aluminum (regional), Renewal by Andersen |
| Customization | Wide range of shapes, grille patterns, and hardware options | Extensive customizations, hundreds of finishes, architectural designs |
| Energy Efficiency | Multiple ENERGY STAR® lines; Low-E coatings; strong noise reduction (Quiet Mark certified) | ENERGY STAR® lines; Fibrex frames offer strong insulation; humidity control |
| Price Range | $200 to $3,000+ per window (depending on series & style) | $200 to $2,500+ per window (depending on series & style) |
| Warranty | 20 years glass, 10 years frame/hardware, 2 years labor | 20 years glass, 20 years frame, 10 years hardware, 5 years labor |
| Best For | Budget-friendly vinyl & fiberglass options; strong energy efficiency | Premium wood & custom designs; white-glove installation (Renewal by Andersen) |
Pella and Andersen have both been in business for over a century. Here’s a brief rundown of what each company can bring to your home.
Founded in 1925, Pella Windows has long been known for innovation and quality craftsmanship. The company makes all their products in the United States, adhering to top-tier manufacturing standards as they create vinyl, wood, and fiberglass frame options, as well as many different types of glass and add-ons. The company has built a reputation on energy-efficient premium windows, with a broad line of products that are functional, stylish, and kind to your wallet. Products are available nationwide.
Andersen Windows was established in 1903 and considered a premium brand from the start. High-quality windows and impressive customizations are the hallmarks of Andersen Windows. All products are made in the USA. The company offers over 35 window types, including several product lines that offer windows to suit every budget. Andersen is especially known for their wood-clad and composite frames, including those made of proprietary Fibrex material.
Pella and Andersen bring competing product lines that serve up unique options and varying price points. Let’s take a look at what to expect when you choose windows from these top-notch brands.
Both Pella and Andersen offer wood windows. Pella offers fiberglass and vinyl as standard options; Andersen offers Fibrex, a proprietary composite material, as well as limited vinyl options through Renewal by Andersen.
| Type of Material | Offered By | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wood | Pella/Andersen | Unsurpassed natural beauty, can last for many decades | Needs regular maintenance, can be pricey |
| Fiberglass | Pella | Strong and durable, very energy-efficient | Not as many options as wood frames, more expensive than vinyl |
| Fibrex | Andersen | Eco-friendly, durable, good insulation | Thicker frames, potential for warping |
| Vinyl | Pella/Andersen | Budget-friendly, easy maintenance | Prone to cracking and discoloration |
Each brand offers flagship product lines, specialty products, and upgrades. The flagship lines include Pella Lifestyle and Andersen 400 Series, both of which can meet a wide range of needs. Here’s a more in-depth look at the products.
Pella’s Lifestyle Series offers the beauty of wood windows as well as innovative features. You can choose smart home capability, integrated blinds, and much more. Exceptional energy efficiency is a standard with the flagship series.
Other options include:
Andersen has many product lines, including their flagship Andersen 400 Series. The 400 Series offers a traditional look, durability, and proprietary Perma-Shield exteriors, which means you will never have to paint them. These vinyl windows are an ideal blend of comfort, style, and affordability.
Other lines include:
Pella and Andersen are comparable in terms of grille patterns and hardware; from classic to modern, each company offers a wealth of choice. Pella offers made-to-order sizing and a variety of shapes available straight from the factory floor; Andersen also offers customization, making tailored designs one of their strong selling points. Both companies offer solidly traditional windows that will suit classic or historic homes, as well as sleek modern options that create a unique look.
Price is where these masters of the window industry really go head-to-head. Here’s a rundown of what to expect from costs from Andersen and Pella.
Pricing for windows from both Pella and Andersen depend upon the type of window you choose, the size of the window, the materials, how many panes of glass, and the complexity of the installation. Other factors, such as the trim and colors you choose, might make a small difference in the bottom line as well.
Andersen Windows start at an average of $200 per window in the 100 series and go up to $2,500 for a window in the A Series or E Series. Here are some of the most common costs you might encounter with particular window styles from Andersen.
| Window Type | Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Awning | $750 to $1,550 |
| Double-hung | $380 to $1,550 |
| Casement | $550 to $2,080 |
| Sliding | $580 to $1,300 |
| Bow or Bay | $2,100 to $3,620 |
Pella Windows also begin at around $200 for the most affordable window and rise to $3,000 or more with the Reserve line. Here’s a breakdown of the costs you might expect from the different window types at Pella:
| Window Type | Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Awning | $400 to $1,600 |
| Double-hung | $400 to $2,000 |
| Casement | $400 to $2,500 |
| Sliding | $200 to $1,000 |
| Bow or Bay | $500 to $3,000 |
Regardless of whether you go with Andersen or Pella, the price of your window doesn’t include local installation costs. Depending upon where you live, that can run between $100 and $350 per window.
It is quite common to see a decrease in utility bills when you have new windows installed, especially if you go for whole-house installation and use a high-quality window, such as those offered by Andersen and Pella.
Pella has done the research on those one, learning that their windows can recoup up to 73% of their value during resale — and in fact, that ROI can kick in as far as 20 years down the line. Andersen keeps their numbers private but homeowners can expect a resale impact as well as savings and comfort. The transferable warranty from Andersen adds significant value if you choose to sell your home.
As companies with a strong history and reputation, both Pella and Andersen offer exceptional warranties for their products. Coverage varies depending upon the window series and the additional features you choose, as well as the installation — in some cases, warranties are only valid if the window is installed by a certified contractor. Here’s a brief overview of what to expect.
| Warranty Coverage | Andersen | Pella |
|---|---|---|
| Glass | 20 Years | 20 Years |
| Frame | 20 Years | 10 Years |
| Hardware | 10 Years | 10 Years |
| Labor/Installation | 5 Years | 2 Years |
Pella and Andersen both have certified contractors, helping ensure that your installation is done well. Andersen offers a 2-year limited warranty on installation and labor. However, you can choose any installer you prefer, keeping in mind that the warranty might be compromised by shoddy workmanship.
Renewal by Andersen is the in-home design and installation team that provides white-glove service from start to finish. Pella, on the other hand, doesn’t have in-house installation teams; rather, they rely on certified contractors. This makes Pella a better choice for those who are into do-it-yourself home renovation.
When two companies offer top-notch products, seeing the advantages and disadvantages side-by-side can help you make an informed decision on which one is right for you.
Pros
Cons
Pros
Cons
When comparing Pella vs Andersen windows, homeowners often want clarity on cost, energy efficiency, warranties, and design options before making a decision. Below are answers to the most common questions to help you choose the brand that best fits your home and budget.
That depends on the product line you choose. Overall, the two brands fall into a similar price range, but Andersen tends to focus more on premium wood and clad products, while Pella offers a broader mix that includes budget-friendly vinyl options. Because of this, Pella is often considered the more affordable choice, while Andersen is typically the higher-end investment.
Both Pella and Andersen are excellent for durability and longevity. Their generous warranties support this, and both companies have been industry leaders for decades. With proper installation and maintenance, you can expect windows from either brand to last 20 to 40 years or more, depending on the material and climate
Yes, you can. Many homeowners choose different brands for different needs, such as premium wood windows in a living room and more affordable vinyl windows in less visible areas. The key is proper installation. Regardless of brand, a skilled and experienced installer will have the biggest impact on performance, efficiency, and lifespan.
Both brands offer ENERGY STAR®-certified options and high-performance glass packages, but Andersen is especially known for superior efficiency in its premium wood-clad and Fibrex® composite lines. Pella also provides excellent efficiency, particularly in its fiberglass and triple-pane models. Ultimately, the specific product line and glass upgrades you choose will determine energy savings.
Both Pella and Andersen back their products with strong warranties, but coverage details differ. Pella typically offers a limited lifetime warranty on non-glass materials and 20 years on insulated glass. Andersen warranties vary by series, with many products carrying 20-year glass coverage and 10 years on non-glass components. Always confirm warranty details for the exact line you’re considering, as coverage can vary.
Andersen leans heavily toward premium wood and wood-clad designs with a wide variety of interior and exterior finishes, making it a favorite for custom or luxury projects. Pella, meanwhile, offers strong versatility with vinyl, fiberglass, and wood lines, giving homeowners more budget flexibility. If you’re prioritizing luxury and custom finishes, Andersen has the edge; if you want a broader mix of materials and price points, Pella may be the better fit.
Installation costs are typically similar for both brands, but Andersen often requires certified installers, which can drive labor pricing higher. Pella also partners with certified contractors but is sometimes available through big-box retailers, which may offer slightly more competitive installation rates. Homeowners should request multiple quotes to compare both labor and material costs before deciding.
Pella and Andersen are titans of the window industry, and for good reason: Each provides top-notch windows, premium materials, the ability to customize, a wide variety of colors and finishes, and warranties that promise your windows will last for many years. The energy-efficiency options with each brand are comparable, meeting or exceeding today’s standards for comfort and savings.
While Pella might be more advantageous for someone on a budget, Andersen also offers wallet-friendly lines. Andersen offers white-glove service and installation, while Pella is better for independent contractors and do-it-yourself homeowners.
The choice of window brand is up to you; however, getting solid quotes on installation for each company will help you determine which one is best for your needs right now.
Ready to take the next step? Visit the Modernize Review Hub to explore installers to consider, compare detailed brand reviews, and get the insights you need to choose with confidence.
Read real homeowner reviews, explore qualifications, and view promotions. Modernize makes it easy to browse professionals and find one that will be perfect for your project.
